The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About01-11-2001 Planning Commission Meeting PacketNOTES Sound is produced by a vibrating object or surface. In order for sound to be transmitted or propagated, it re- r quires an elastic medium. The most common medium for transmission is the air. Such sound is called "air -borne sound." However, sound can also be easily transmitted through common building materials and components such as steel, concrete, wood and metal framing, piping, and gypsum wallboard. This type of sound is called "structure -borne sound." A- weighted decibel (dB(A)I is a standard single- number rating representing the overall sound energy of a given source. The A- weighting network in a sound level meter filters sound in a manner similar to the human ear by downgrading low frequencies. FREQUENCY OF COMMON SOUNDS DECIBEL SCALE The decibel (dB) scale is a logarithmic scale based on 10 times the logarithm of a ratio of sound pressures. The decibel levels of two noise sources can not be added directly; instead use this simplified method: difference between two sound levels, in d6 0 - 1 2 - 3 4 - 9 >10 add to the higher level 3 2 1 0 For example: 90 dB + 20 dB = 90 dB 60 dB + 60 dB = 63 dB OCTAVE BAND An octave band covers the range from one frequency (Hz) to twice that frequency, f to 2f. SUBJECTIVE FACTORS: EFFECT OF CHANGE IN SOUND PRESSURE LEVEL CHANGE IN SOUND PRESSURE Very loud LEVEL (+ OR CHANGE IN APPARENT LOUDNESS 3 Barely perceptible 5 Clearly noticeable 10 Dramatic: Twice as loud (OR ' /z) 15 Dramatic: Three times as loud ON PIANO (OR '/3) 20 Dramatic: Four times as loud street (OR '/4) I i TYPE OF SOUND I FREQUENCY OR PITCH (HZ) L OW FREQUENCY MID -- FREQUENCY HIGH FREQUENCY I OCTAVE �` 16 315 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 6000 16000 31500 z LOW PEDAL STOP Power mower, 100 Very loud ON ORGAN i horn at 10 ft HIGHEST NOTE Propeller plane flyover at Full symphony or band, 90 ON PIANO food blender, noisy street factory RANGE OF HUMAN Diesel truck at 40 mph at Inside auto at high speed, 80 Moderately loud 50 ft garbage disposal, SPEECH dishwasher AREA OF MOST Face -to -face SPEECH INTELLIGIBILITY conversation, vacuum 70 Loud cleaner, electric BALLAST HUM FROM typewriter FLUORESCENTS AND General office 60 Moderate condenser at 15 ft, near HARMONICS freeway auto traffic 50 Quiet DESKTOP COMPUTERS 100 ft WITH DISK DRIVE Private office, soft radio 40 OFFICE EQUIPMENT music in apartment Quiet residential Bedroom, average (PRINTERS, TYPEWRITERS, Very quiet neighborhood residence without stereo 20 TELEPHONES) Quiet theater, whisper 10 Just audible TRUCKS, BUSES Threshold of hearing HUMAN HEARING *OCTAVE — A FREQUENCY RATIO OF 2 =1 RELATIONSHIP OF SOUND LEVEL AND SUBJECTIVE LOUDNESS ENVIRONMENT SOUND LEVEL OUTDOOR I (oBA) SUBJECTIVE EVALUATIONS 140 Deafening Near jet aircraft and artillery fire 130 Threshold of pain NDOOR 120 Threshold of feeling Elevated train Hard rock band 110 Jet flyover at 1000 ft Inside propeller plane COMMENTS _� o ra a Y a� 0 X o o zr E c m 0— > o o . ° 0 U ev O .0 w O L O U c c�i eo d Cr. 0 Carl J. Rosenberg, AIA; Accentech Inc.; Cambridge, Massachusetts ACOUSTICAL DESIGN Power mower, 100 Very loud motorcycle at 25 ft, auto horn at 10 ft Propeller plane flyover at Full symphony or band, 90 1000 ft, noisy urban food blender, noisy street factory Diesel truck at 40 mph at Inside auto at high speed, 80 Moderately loud 50 ft garbage disposal, dishwasher Face -to -face conversation, vacuum 70 Loud cleaner, electric typewriter Air conditioning General office 60 Moderate condenser at 15 ft, near freeway auto traffic 50 Quiet Large transformer at 100 ft Birdcalls Private office, soft radio 40 music in apartment Quiet residential Bedroom, average 30 Very quiet neighborhood residence without stereo 20 Rustling leaves Quiet theater, whisper 10 Just audible 0 Threshold of hearing COMMENTS _� o ra a Y a� 0 X o o zr E c m 0— > o o . ° 0 U ev O .0 w O L O U c c�i eo d Cr. 0 Carl J. Rosenberg, AIA; Accentech Inc.; Cambridge, Massachusetts ACOUSTICAL DESIGN • DRYER NOISE EMITTING TEST Test Site: Roadrunn Car Wash 1 530 E. Bell Road phoenix, AZ Product Tested: Hun icane Touch -Free Dryer Manufactured by Superior Car Wash Systems, Inc. Model 35-192,4 Nozzlcs, 40 H.P. . S taridard dryer without noise reduction coating Building Housing 1 8" Wide x 12' High x 40' Long . Product Vested: Masonry Nulls, Metal Roof No sound absorbing materials used. Testin g Equipment: ui meat: Edmont. Sound Level Meter Mode[ 60 -540, Manufactured by Edmont Wilson, Coshocton, OH Testing Performed Fly: David J. vary Bmggcn Tester's ualifieat�ons: Mr, vary Bruggen has been a car wash equipment engineer Q since 1967 and employed by Superior since 1991 Testing Procedures: Testing g was pefformed on a c �s clear day with no wind and temperat averaging 85 degrees t 80 feet during he testi period- Noise sacn►ple readings were taken at 10 foot increments up a g g P test with all four 10 away the d er. The dryer was !c# running continuously during the es yry ope rating. All readin are noted on the reverse side and have been verifred b H.P. motors y g � Mr. van Bruggen. xre " -too HRURICANE DRYER MODEL 35-192 a NOZZLE, ao �eoe Note: Ambient noise levels from street traffic, etc. measured 65 dBA with dryer not running. � 101 86 dBA 20 Sx d$A 30 W ow - .... 78 dBA 40 75 dBA 74 dBA l r , fa I MW 73 dBA 70' n dBA Testtg procedures on the reverse si de. rte« 8o 7� dBA Cf. a-% 14 4r. 46p.o t) C d.d ell 6 P 4_11 onow j -7 0-0 Ae 1 %c to tc) * :6/. 41h < > ,o , PEO 1 p U ! L' Gf , . -� s ,' 4p 7- 4 Ito Lu LL 1 to J, LU ZZ LL a in LLI �� < LIJ Lij 5 } WWI. U, p = - ,zE � b WM � � �, � ,, ,1 loc 2o!rtdu no LU .. � � i WNW � 1 t ..� .� ---- rt e' . - " .4b Ila 1" 4D . .............. ............. . I ... ...................... LIJ 416 t sim Lu S1W CL LU ;45 HP DWI 1, i � 1 1 Cf. a-% 14 4r. 46p.o t) C d.d ell P 4_11 onow j -7 0-0 Ae 1 %c to tc) * :6/. 41h < > ,o I owa Q, 4p 4 4 1 to L;J ZZ Lij 5 WWI. U, z LLJ b WM ............ Ila 1" Cf. a-% 14 4r. 46p.o t) C d.d ell f, aldoad isow 10 But •Jeay 041 ape,Bap 01 AJaIJg 91 a,ay anog ainsodxs snonuiiuo:) � 3 t 3 s N N . W Z O J W F- V do% W 3 � • Z < j W { • g. 80 mot > W' ]rL at C O us • z r v U. IL s % o o g to fa < Z O 2 w aldoad isow 10 But •Jeay 041 ape,Bap 01 AJaIJg 91 a,ay anog ainsodxs snonuiiuo:) � 3 t 3 s NORTHWEST ASSOCIATED CO SULTAN 1 5775 Wayzata Boulevard, Sure 555, St. Louis Park, MN 55416 Telephone: 952.595.9636 Facsimile: 952.595.9837 planners@nacplanning.com I' planning.com MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: DATE: RE: FILE NO: Tom Melena Scott Richards January 3, 2001 Oak Park Heights — Cover Manor Zoning 798.02— 00.16 ENCLOSURE q As a follow up to the December 14, 2000 Planning Commission meeti . g g, y staff has done additional research on bed and breakfasts as well as review lot sizes i the Village and Upper neighborhoods of Oak Park . Hei hts Please find as follows information Heights. � oration to assist the Planning Commission in its discussion related to expanding p g the bed and breakfast use. 1. We have mapped the Upper and Village neighborhoods with lot size land d use and zoning information. The attached tables show the potential for multiple unit . p p bed and breakfast facilities even with the proposed condition limiting the use to . g 3,000 square feet per unit. Kris Danielson and I drove the Upper neighborhood . pp g and identified a number of larger, older homes that have potential for bed and .. p breakfast facilities. Many of the houses are located along ecan Avenue some e with views of the river. The Village neighborhood also has p otential homes and properties would support bed and breakfast facilities. 2. We received a copy of the bed and breakfast regulations of the City of Still . g y ate r (see attached. Additionally, I had a conversation with Sue Fritz erald the City g � Y Planner, regarding her experiences with bed and breakfast facilities. The largest bed and breakfast existing in Stillwater is the Rlvertown Inn with a total of nine units. Ms. Fritzgerald indicated that the Stillwater regulations have worked well to control the bed and breakfast business in the City and that none of the facilities have been subject to major complaints or issues raised by g the single family neighbors. 3. Chuck Dougherty has proposed an option of allowing the bed and breakfast use 40 under the R -1, Single Family District with the conditions distributed by staff at the December meeting and with additional conditions adopted from the Stillwater ordinance. Attached please find a memo from Mr. Dougherty gherty with the additional conditions as well as the staff conditions. Mr. Dougherty brings forward an attractive option, especially with the spacing requirements • p g q ents and requiring the structure to be at least 100 years old. B adding appropriate conditions, Y g pp opriate conditions, it may be reasonable to allow the bed and breakfast uses in both the R -1 and R -2 Districts. At their January meting, the Planning Commission should f • further discuss the issues related to the Zoning Ordinance and allowances for bed and breakfasts. In that the Doughertys requested a specific zoning change in Nov • g g ember, their application is subject to the 120 day review requirement. The Planning g Commission will need to make a recommendation and the City Council act on that specific February. request by the end of pc: Kris Danielson I* n u Village of Oak Park Heights Lot Area Analysis 1428 1481 1519 1572 1571 1570 1633 1653 1376 1695 1517 1694 1779 1762 1787 1770 1807 1568 1373 1422 1478 1514 1357 1421 1467 1502 1553 1376 1424 5 1479 1517 1691 1568 1567 1631 1689 1652 1685 1691 1779 1761 1759 1770 1806 1803 1860 1857 1562 1566 1584 1639 1668 1679 1 1 9 � 1820 8 1 1943 1 1788 1974 1 3 1996 1 1995 2056 2105 2103 FI) 2101 0 200 400 Feet 1690 1689 1687 1685 1779 1778 17TT 1801 1802 1821 1826 tl 1872 1825 1893 1679 1 1 9 � 1820 8 1 1943 1 1788 1974 1 3 1996 1 1995 2056 2105 2103 FI) 2101 0 200 400 Feet CLIP _ID AREA ACRES LANDUSE ZONING 1357 20 0.5 Low Density Residential R -1 1373 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1375 1 0.0 Low Density Residential R -1 1376 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1421 15,665.61 0.4 Low Density Residential R -1 1422 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1424 10,140.52 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1428 12 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1467 13 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1478 10,510.49 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1479 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1481 12,343.13 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1502 11 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1514 10,500.04 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1517 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1519 12,332.41 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1553 8 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1562 10 0.2 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1566 7,966.72 0.2 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1567 14 0.3 Industrial R -1 1568 14,957.64 0.3 Industrial R -1 1570 9 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1571 9 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1572 9 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1584 28,484.94 0.7 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1631 26,876.29 0.6 Industrial R -1 1633 28,486.34 0.7 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1639 31,102.18 0.7 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1652 32,868.26 0.8 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1653 31 0.7 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1668 6 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 1679 27,385.88 0.6 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1681 3 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1682 498.40 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1683 518.30 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1684 2 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1685 12 0.3 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1687 19,769.61 0.5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1688 745.50 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1689 6 0.1 Low Density Residential R -1 1690 21 0.5 Low Density Residential R -1 1691 15 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1694 7 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1695 15,040.72 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1752 954.18 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1754 63.19 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1759 14 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1761 6 0.1 Low Density Residential R -1 1762 15,040.29 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1763 709.11 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1764 279.74 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1770 9 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1771 332.72 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1772 221.11 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1773 1774 221.44 138.82 0.0 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 R -2 1775 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1777 20 0.5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1778 8 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1779 10 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 CLIP _ID AREA ACRES LANDUSE ZONING 1780 36.10 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1781 2 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1782 326.26 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1783 527.59 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0 1784 1785 376.02 3 0.0 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 R -2 1786 511.38 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1787 30,067.42 0.7 Low Density Residential R -1 1788 83 1.9 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1789 2 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1790 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1791 4 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1792 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1793 9 0.2 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1799 753.90 0.0 R -1 1801 6 0.1 Low Density Residential R -1 1802 8 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1803 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1806 11,241.79 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1807 22 0.5 Low Density Residential R -1 1812 168.06 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1813 159.16 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1814 610.38 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1815 137.52 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1816 869.92 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1817 592.95 0.0 R -1 1818 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1811 2 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1820 20,585.57 : 0 -. 5 - Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1821 12 - 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 * 822 14,000.12 0.3 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1823 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1825 25 0.6 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1826 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1857 12,077.68 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1860 11 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1872 6 0.1 Low Density Residential R -1 1876 1.91 0.0 R -2 1878 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1888 1,356.77 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1893 7 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1902 364.41 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1933 9 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1935 7 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1936 15 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1937 44,905.29 1.0 Low Density Residential R -1 1940 19 0.5 Low Density Residential R -1 1941 161.85 0.0 Low Density Residential R -2 1942 1 0.0 Low Density Residential R -2 1943 12,507.17 0.3 Low Density Residential R -2 1946 10 0.2 Low Density Residential R -2 1947 3 0.1 1948 18,899.58 0.4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1965 20 0.5 Low Density Residential R -1 1972 1 0.0 Low Density Residential R -2 1973 228.97 0.0 R -2 974 15,105.61 0.3 Low Density Residential R -2 1978 11 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 1979 7 0.2 Low Density Residential R -1 1993 684.24 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 CLIP - I D AREA ACRES LANDUSE ZONING 199 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1995 22,569.31 0.5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 1996 15,000.62 0.3 Low Density Residential R -2 1997 7 0.2 Low Density Residential R -2 1998 3 0.1 Low Density Residential R -2 1999 4 0.1 2000 24,987.55 0.6 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2004 22,602.62 0.5 Low Density Residential R -1 2021 5 0.1 Low Density Residential R -1 2035 2 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2037 15 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 2046 18 0.4 Low Density Residential R -1 2055 1 0.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2056 9 0.2 Low Density Residential R -2 2058 3 0.1 R -1 2085 3 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2089 250.50 0.0 R -2 2098 2 0.1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2101 28,368.77 0.7 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2103 20,930.71 0.5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2105 20,926.35 0.5 Vacant/Undeveloped .Land R -2 2110 943.41 0.0 Low Density Residential R -2 2117 66,906.92 1.5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 2137 6 0.2 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2139 14,112.17 0.3 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 2149 66 1.5 R -1 2150 15,003.48 0.3 Low Density Residential R -1 2151 75,050.33 1.7 R -1 2306 42 1.0 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 2313 104,786.36 2.4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -1 2436 18,347.97 0.4 Low Density Residential R -2 2464 5 0.1 Low Density Residential R -2 2465 13,198.33 0.3 Low Density Residential R -2 2471 16,942.52 0.4 Low Density Residential R -2 1938 90 2.1 Low Density Residential R -1 1704 28,208.81 56.2 Park Facilities R -1 1704 11,463.15 56.2 Park Facilities R -1 E - 7 10 Upper Oak Park Heights Lot Area Analysis 1 567 373 1 1 72 371 370 369 368 367 366 424 423 422 421 249 254 253 252 251 250 583 625 408 260 623622 621 295 310 303 1 02 301 300 299 298 297 373 1 1 72 371 370 369 368 367 366 424 423 422 421 420 419 492491490 481 480 489 488 487 486 485 483 530 529 528 527 t 6 525 524 523 Nat January 2001 248 481 480 479 243 242 241 240 247246245244 - -531 -_ 590 589 588 587 586 585 584 583 625 408 623622 621 620 629 618 630 Nat January 2001 248 481 480 479 243 242 241 240 247246245244 360 383 517 292 291 290289 394 288 287 307 482 481 480 479 478 365 363 362 361 360 383 517 516 515 538 394 779 408 431 418 417 416 414 413 412 443 456 482 481 480 479 478 476 511 520 519 518 517 516 515 538 582 581 580 578 577 576 574 573 607 6 614 613 612 611 610 609 640 661 670 709 701 759 758 757 806 668 667 690 708 706 755 \ 731 779 666 663 662 68 686 695 7 703 J754 734 778 800 7 816 96 851 848 844 889 0 872 847 979 200 0 200 400 Feet CLIP _ID AREA LANDUSE ZONING ACRES 0 27,459.16 R -2 0.6 213 31,886.71 Low Density Residential R -2 0.7 214 19 Low Density Residential R -2 0.5 215 6 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 216 6 R -2 0.1 240 18 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 241 10,778.82 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 242 10,784.99 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 243 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 244 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 245 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 246 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 247 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 248 6 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 249 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 250 16 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 251 16,239.81 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 252 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 253 10,835.44 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 254 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 260 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 287 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 288 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 289 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 290 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 291 10,792.84 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 292 16,193.95 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 293 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 294 _- 5,401.02 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 295 3 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 297 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 298 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 299 12,720.61 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 300 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 301 13 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 302 2,698.75 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 303 10,839.68 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 307 13 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 308 533.55 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 310 12,231.05 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 312 2 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 319 701.25 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.0 320 946.47 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.0 321 2 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 324 8 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 325 10,576.53 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 326 1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.0 328 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 331 13,611.41 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 340 14 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 358 4 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 360 15,397.32 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 361 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 362 10,787.19 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 363 24 Low Density Residential R -2 0.6 365 13 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 366 10,811.67 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 367 10,816.69 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 368 16,231.28 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 369 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 CLIP _ID AREA LANDUSE ZONING ACRES 370 10,829.87 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 371 13,543.08 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 372 2 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 373 10,841.79 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 383 386 4 11 Vacant/Undeveloped Land Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 R -2 0.3 391 15,886.79 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 392 1 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 393 132.75 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 394 4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 397 510.44 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 408 4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 412 10,778.82 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 413 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 414 10 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 416 16,189.15 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 417 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 418 10,804.14 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 419 16,216.22 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 420 16 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 421 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 422 10,831.12 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 423 16,254.10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 424 10,842.42 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 427 8 Low ,Density Residential R -2 0.2 428 1 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 431 4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 440 15 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 441 2 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 443 4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 456 4 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 460 979.10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 461 26 Low Density Residential R -2 0.6 476 18,467.41 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 478 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 479 16 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 480 10,792.21 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 481 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 482 16,200.54 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 483 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 485 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 486 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 487 10,823.28 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 488 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 489 18,279.70 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 490 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 491 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 492 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 500 22 Low Density Residential R -2 0.5 511 12 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 513 20 Low Density Residential R -2 0.5 515 10,782.49 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 516 10,787.19 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 517 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 518 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 519 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 520 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 523 16 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 524 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 525 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 CLIP _ID AREA LANDUSE ZONING ACRES 526 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 527 10,827.79 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 528 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 529 530 12 10,841.48 Low Density Residential Low Density Residential R -2 R -2 0.3 0.2 538 12 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 542 19,013.74 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 567 19 School Facilities R -2 0.5 569 17 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 573 13,609.10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 574 5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 576 10,782.17 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 577 16,180.06 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 578 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 580 6 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 581 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 582 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 583 10,808.53 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 584 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 585 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 586 6 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 587 6 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 588 8,117.06 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 589 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 590 10,829.97 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 591 1 0 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 598 13,297.70 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 607 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 609 10,779.66 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 610 5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 611 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 612 13 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 613 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 614 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 615 4 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 617 1 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 618 10,812.61 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 620 10,820.61 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 621 10,825.16 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 622 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 623 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 624 11,029.01 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 625 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 628 19 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 629 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 630 9 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 640 9,237.08 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 651 86.73 0.0 662 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 663 12,065.29 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 666 2 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.0 667 16,808.50 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 668 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 669 14 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 670 13,675.68 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.3 672 10,502.18 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 673 5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 674 5,840.23 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 675 17 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 677 16 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 CLIP AREA LANDUSE ZONING ACRES 679 15,812.07 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 686 5 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 687 1,613.62 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.0 689 762.44 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 690 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 695 7 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 696 1 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.0 697 147.59 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 701 10 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 703 10,915.41 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 704 640.89 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 705 598.15 R -2 0.0 706 21,859.69 Low Density Residential R -2 0.5 707 1 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 708 17,581.69 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 709 12,676.54 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 713 2 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 734 21 Low Density Residential R -2 0.5 735 1,148.34 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 737 116.35 R -2 0.0 749 12,876.41 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 751 1 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 754 2 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 755 8 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 757 10,292.92 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 758 10,378.30 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 759 11 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 778 2 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 779 15 Low Density Residential R -2 0.4 781 1,172.69 Low Density Residential R -2 0.0 784 4 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 788 10,816.84 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 796 10,879.24 Low Density Residential R -2 0.2 800 3 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 806 11,739.50 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 815 11,702.50 Low Density Residential R -2 0.3 816 3 Low Density Residential R -2 0.1 844 5 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.1 847 20,504.71 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.5 848 11,205.68 High Density Residential R -2 0.3 851 11,217.68 High Density Residential R -2 0.3 872 15,025.21 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.3 889 5 High Density Residential R -2 0.1 979 10 Vacant/Undeveloped Land R -2 0.2 12/14/2000 10: 45 4308810 # 31 -t CITY OF STILLWATER PAGE e2 IRRf� � STEM WAMM CODE C. Front yam: 50 feet when not within a PUD. d. Rear yard: 25 feet when not within a PUD. e. Building sad imperAotg surfaces: 60 percent when not within a PUD. f. Landscaping and open space: 40 per- C*nt when not within a PUTS. g. Additional setback requirements: When a property within this dis tinct ie dir+ectl}r Rems a street or thorough- fare or adjacent to any residential district, all parking and loading fa. cili ties must be at least 20 feet from the property line and buildings and structures at least 20 feet f-o th street. The setback space must be permanently landscaped. h* tuber requi!,rements: All uses shall be conducted wholly within co m. pl+etsly enclosed buildings, except for service stations, parking facilities an other outdoor uses when approp ri. ately located and dmigned as ap- proved by the planfUng Commissio ( Duien permit. A design review permit is '*maim for all village commereiel um. The muntry vfflaV architectural and de - algn guidelines, set forth in Exhibit E to It the OrdMy Annexation Agmment b tar+aen the City an d To o f Stillwater, dated August le, 19 , are the standaW that must be applied to this design re view. (6) Planned unit detw1opment, These develop- ment requirements may be modified based on an acceptable planned unit develop- ment for the entire village commercial district area. (Ord. No. 8M, 9-3-96) Sind. 24. Supplementary regulations. Supple - mentary regulations governing this Section are as follows: Exception $ions or vuxi#UWion& The pm visions of this subdivision are subject to they exceptions, additions or modifications as met forth In the following; ( 1 ) EwentW oervicesr. ' Essential services, as defined in this subdivision, am permitted in all districts. (2) Soil strippins. No person may strip, exca- vate or otherwise remove topsoil ibr sate, or for use other than on the premises from which it is taken, except in eonnecdon with the construction or alteration of a building on the premises and any incidee- tal excavation or grading. . (3) Va wnt l ots of reco Notwithstanding the lirm tations impewed by any other pro - Visions of this subdivision, the city conned may permit ere ction of a dwelling on any lot (except a lot in an industrial district), separRLOy owned or under contract of sale and containing, on May 1, lW4, area or width smaller than that required for a one-family dwelling, provided that municipal sewer and water service is avail- able to the site. (4) Clear corners. O a corner lot in any resi dential district no fence, wall, bad or other structure or planting mote than three feet in height maybe , placed or maintained within the triangular azea firmed by the intersecting istreet lines and A straight line n 4joining the attet lines at points which are 40 feet distant morn the point of intersection, provided that this regulation does not apply to trees trimmed to a height of eight feet above the stet grade level. (5) Substandard lots. No lot, yard, court or other open space, already containi less area than the Minimum required under this subdivision, may be further divided or reduced. 7(6) Bad and brew fast. The city council re - nises that bed and breakfa e eats a� an a CD31 :56 r-� u MATER PAGE 03 0 ZONING 31 -1 . to the immunity end he the tian of historic h � pr�erva- +awes becau the ex b. The dining facilities tt�u $t n be Penes of wing and maintaining historic open to the �ubiic and must be sed homOB has made them less BWtabl. f exclusively by the rsgist"W eats single - family dwel ` C )jugs, ver$ion oft is. s- u u.less allowed as a to e�epar�t t, toric houses into multi 11Y us" in uOu- ally determia d by the neigbb,thoad tied or special use, w it is located. It is the h More the intention of the pity to limit quad breslcfsat uses to e' Bed and t uses is n tial atria must be located those horses where the use would the aurreu� b er a by at t 900 feet apart Cap ally ap�pr0. P'liaw a daptive reuse of historic dwell- bla�)- lngs Bed and breWasts are aired b s�°8i use Permf t in RB Y a and RCM zoning d. An identification si�rY nat i four districts as regulated in thin s+ecti sub 13{l)c and square feet m m be loca on the sits. The sign mast � subdi 1) �� to � ��II 14(1 Bub- e fi�lkjwing co�ndjta�8, the ahitectu feats o f t, c - a. At least two o!f "stmt Pa r icing tore. spaces m ust be provided flrwite f0 r the own or m�a8'+ea• and one �$' Bpaee e. � and breast establi to for each bed and breakfast are prohibited in all other . d's . waft, Z'he - sig ned Fai' spat,. must be wed and the �� plan ap•- f The land and t st�uctu list pr�$d by the m munftY d be at least 100 Years old or ow went �" • proof of historic a �i the - -- Ci t g. The masuncun of fivs followi Eo bed and breakaet gu,6rue m a be . � t axYd structure sire criteria d,etermi established m a structure e Maximum nos the number Of gueaa allow Number oHgin l G roo N oar ° f Mires Maximum Goss moues S - �u � Perm . t d N� fa�txd� V mcnt L&0 Its Sq uare Feet in squam t Z S Up to 2 7 400 3 � 29 10,000 3900" 109,000 0 3#500-4tM 115V000 Maxim �� house sire is determ�;ned 5 u 20oQ00 li b usi �ng spade within the st uctum• Th Y ng th totai squam footage of hibi Ie a number of original in determine the number of �.�+est�roo,B,e that by the herit preaervatjQn co mjrs�on bedroom use must be be determined the 9"et � HI will be allowed. This d u de termination will be de �n the case of a famil �� Y children the mirj , be fare the numb f W ed, amd no farnjl�r member must be displaced t number o perra 8u�troom, mitted gu'�tmma are d er C1 us? r, u 12/14/2000 10:45 4308810 # 51 -1 CITY OF ET I LLWATER ST LLMTU CODE PACE 04 h. Adequate hghtuYg must be provided a distance of ten feet fhm the stet between the structure and parking right of -way. Dedduous WW sh$11 areas for safety contiguous to reel be planted 40 feet on center, and dential structures. coniferous street trees shall be i. Additional external lighting is pro- planted 30 feet on center. hibited. C. The minimum front yard on devsl� j, An establishment must show proof aped '601tI crereia! and industrial Iota of city building, fire and planning shall be covered with sod and main - inspections, proof of operation li' tained in an appropriate wanner. censes by the county and must sub- d. Portions of l intended to be uti- mit the state sales and use tax num lied for expansion of structures may ber for their bus iness a to the be seeded with grass seed, mulched cxmmunity de"lopment department, and fertilized according to the rac- k. Restoration or additions must meet ommendations of the zoning admin- the Secretary of Interioes standards istrator instead of bein nodded. for rehabilitation. e• Planting is lands ' in parldng tots shall 1. All bad and b,reakf t as speci use be slanted with at least one dedd P ermits must be revi+eu►ed annually ous tree and at least two shrubs and by the community development de- shall be mulched with a minimum of partment. A report must be submit- � � or four inch of wood chi es on and tad to the planning commission city council during November ofeach similar material. . All p lantin g is- year lands shalt be treats�d�with a mechan- *ad weed inhabiter. One tube for (7) Farm animals, In all districts any lot fft &ng and watering shall be i . upon farm animals are kept must stalled in each land island. p be at least three atone in size. Farm animab are defined as: horses, ewe, sheep, f. All plant materials indicated on an bees, pigs, chickens, ducks, rabbita and approved l and ping plan that do other commonly known domestic farm an- not survive two growing moons shall imals. be replace with identical plants dur- (8) Pate building& Pole buildings are pro►hi.b. ing or before the following season. ited in all zoning districts. (10) Prgkction into required yard ate. Every (9) Minimum landscape r+sgr menu. In the part of a required yard shall be *pea and BP-C, BP -0, EP -I, CBD, CA and PEA son- unobstructed by any building or structure ing districts, the following minimum land except for the fbUowinir, scaping requirements must be met for all a. Awnings, sills, cornices, buttresses, projects: eaves, landings and neceamw steps a. Minimum plant size is as follows: and similar architectural features may project into required yard a ► � Sin distance of not more than three feet 1. tress t - IV2 iUchM so long as the pru ection is not cleeer exapw than three feet from the prapettY I Deg Wuow shrubs 18 hwbm bah line. 3. Conifemus eye e m a to 3% Ant higb b. Openwork fire balconies and fum ee- 4. Caaitwofua shmbe i gWke capes may extend not more thin b. fees shall be planted along all three feet into the required side or streets. Street trees shall be set back rear yard. CD8 1:58 I* n L-A 0 At the December Planning Commission meeting, there were two issues brought forward: • How to avoid future. potential of the property being converted into apartments. • How to control the growth of Bed &Breakfasts in other areas of the city. Both these issues can be handled with the following changes: Change Bed and Breakfast to a Conditional Use under R-1, Single Family Residential District, instead of R -2. With the following conditions: Add to the ,sit_ of twelve conditions presented at the last planning commission meeting. m) Bed &Breakfasts must be located at least 900 feet apart (approximately three blocks). n) Bed &Breakfasts are prohibited in all other districts o) The Bed &Breakfast must be at least 100 years old. P) All Bed &Breakfast special use permits must be reviewed annually by the community development department. q) Bed &Breakfast special use permits are nontransferable. 0 CITY OF OAK PARK HEIGHTS Conditions for a Bed and Breakfast / Inn Facilities a) A maximum of ten (10) bed and breakfast units may be established within a structure. b) The facility shall have a State issued license for lodging and food service g 9 ,and comply with and maintain all health, safety, building, and fire codes as may be required or applicable. c) Facilities shall be operated by the owner - occupant of the residential property on which the bed and breakfast is proposed. d) All bed and breakfast units shall be established within the principal structure. e) The principal .structure shall have a minimum size of one thousand seven hundred fifty (1,750) gross square feet. f) The parcel on which the bed and breakfast is located shall accommodate at least three thousand (3,000) square feet of lot area per bed and breakfast unit exclusive of the owner- occupants' living quarters. g) Not more than the equivalent of two (2) full time persons shall be employed by the bed and breakfast facilities who are not residents of the structure. h) Dining and other facilities shall not be opened to the public but shall be used d exclusively by the residents, registered guests of the or facility, guests of an event or meeting held at the facility. i) The owner- occupant of the bed and breakfast shall be allowed t0 host events ) small groups and meetings if the facility contains at least one thousand 1 000 square feet of area exclusively for this purpose as well as a commercial kitchen that complies with all health, safety, and building code standards. j) Two (2) off - street parking spaces sha!I be provided for the facility plus one (1) for each bed and breakfast unit. Parking areas shall be screened and landscaped and no parking space shall be located in the front yard of the property, other than on an existing driveway. The parking areas shall be improved with asphalt, but shall be exempt from other commercial parking requirements of the Zoning Ordinance. 9 u k) Not more than one (1) identification sign not exceeding six (6) square feet in area • may be located on the premises. The sign shall be reflective of the architectural features in the structure and may not be externally or internally illuminated. I) Adequate lighting shall be provided between the principal structure and the parking area for the safety of guests. All external lighting shall be regulated by conditional use permit. I* 0 Meeting Date: Agenda Item Title: Time Required: January 9, 2001 Schedule interview session with commission applicants. 2 Minutes 5 Agenda Placement: Consent Agenda Originating Department /Requestor: Community Development /Julie Hultman Requester's Signature: Action Requested: Schedule interview session with commission applicants and query them as to their preference to be appointed to either Pars or Planning. Background /Justification (Please indicate if an previous action has been taken or if other pubic bodies have advised) We currently have two vacancies on the Planning Commission and one on the Pars Commission. Four Planning Commission applications have been received and a fifth is expected. It is my suggestion that we inform the applicants of the vacancies on both commissions and inquire as to their desire to be appointed to one or the other and then conduct interviews to fill the vacancies on both the Pars and Planning Commissions. Date/Time Received Financial Implications $ Budget Budgeted: Yes City Administrator /Date Line Item No Funding: Levy Other Administrative Recommendation: Approve Deny Comments: 0 Oak Park Heights Request for Council Action No Recommendation SAS HARED \Forms \COUNCIL ACTION REQUEST.doc 00 NORTHWEST ASSOCIATED C _ ONSULTANTS INC COMMUNITY PLANNING DESIGN - MARKET RESEARCH • MEMORANDUM TO: Tom Melena ENCLOSURE 6 FROM: Scott Richards DATE: October 4, 2000 RE: Oak Park Heights - Public /Institutional and Open Space Zoning District FILE N0: 798.04 - 00.03 The City Council, at their September 26 2000 meeting, voted to send consideration of the Public/Institutional and Open Space Zoning D' p g istrict back to the Planning C omm i ssion. The City Council requested that staff notif all the affected parties such as churches School District, cemetery ,the ry wners, the State of Minnesota (correctional facilit Metropolitan Council and the Metro p (wastewater facility) regarding the p ropose d Further g p p d zoning text changes. the City Council requested that once notification has been completed, the Planning Commission hold a meeting ith the ' g representatives of the affected land uses. The City Council wanted assurance before the ' Zoning Ordnance is revised and especially chang affects p y before an actual zoning g cts the properties in question, that all of the a parties understand the zoning amendments. As you are the changes es th b st 9 at have been prop osed y ff and recommended by the Planning to the 9 include amendments only Zoning Ordinance text. Rezoning parcels o g p t the Public /Institutional District would be done by a separate action including public g a p is hearing of the Planning Commission and City Council action. City Council members commented on the proposed setback standards for the Public/Institutional District. The rims concern p ry of the Council was if certain uses such as churches would meet the standards as proposed. ' p p .Staff indicated that the existing would b g uses are grandfathered and they e allowed to remain and expand, as Ion as the nonconformity was not increased. Fu 9 Further, staff has not proposed a rezoning . Calvary Ass g of the two churches �n the Cat Y ry embly and First Presbyterian Church are both c urrently zoned residential in which churches are and would remain an allowable conditional nd�tlonal use. The proposed rezoning being considered at this time is limited to public facilities such as City Hall and parks, schools, cemeteries the ' correct�ona! facility and the Metropolitan Council's wastewater facility. 5775 WAYZATA BOULEVARD, SUITE 555 ST. LOUIS PARK, MINNESOTA 554 1 6 PHONE 61 2- 595 -9636 FAX 61 2- 595 -9837 E -MAIL NAC@ WINTERNET.COM AW k The City Attorney commented on the proposed Public /Institutional Distric permitted � ct and indicated that while City parks are p in the proposed ordinance, similar recreational facilities for schools would be considered as conditional. Mr. Vierling felt that the be treated in a similar manner no matter same uses should what organization or jurisdiction arks be made +s their sponsor. He suggested that p a conditional use within the Public/ • Staff has recommended Public/institutional District. Sta • n , as attached, to add parks, recreational fac buildi s as a conditional ' structures or 9 nd�tional use under Section 401.320.E • of the proposed district. The language has been drafted with the intent that minor changes to parks would not require a conditional use permit, but that all major facilities, q . ng Commission should � buildings and parking .areas The Planning p 9 would. comment on this change as they consider the ad staff and Council input o this ' additional p n issue. pc: Kris Danielson ► i 2 I* J'' PROPOSED ORDINANCE CHANGES: I* Section 401.320.D. Accessory Uses MVTV - M OUT T . _ WMIENK0 TM; ja�'MAKMKPYATA win Comment: This item is no longer applicable and should be removed, if the use is moved to the conditional section. Section 401.320E Conditional Uses 1. Private and public pre - school, elementary, ry, or senior high schools and related recreational fields and facilities, provided that .... Comment: The wording "and related recreational fields ' ' ' and facilities has been added to clarify the meaning and what is included under this sectio 7. Public parks and related recreational fields major str uctures, uctures, buildings and parking areas, provided that: a. Adequate distance and screening from abutting residential uses and landscaping is provided in compliance with Section 401.15.E of this Ordinance. b. Adequate off- street parking and access is rovided ' p on the site or lots directly abutting across a public street or alley o the principal use in ' Y p p compliance with Section 401.15.E of this Ordinance and that such arki p ng is adequately screened and landscaped from surrounding and abutting esidential 9 uses in compliance with Section 401.15.E of this Ordinance. C. All lighting of buildings, structures and facilities shall be in conformance with Section 401.15.6.7 of this Ordinance. d. The provisions of Section 401.03.A.8 of this Ordinance are considered and satisfactorily met. Comment: A new section is added for arks and related facilities ' p as a conditional use. 8. Private outdoor recreational areas including golf course ' 9 g s, country clubs, swimming pools and other similar facilities, provided that: + Comment. The word private is added to differentiate these from outdoor recreational area public facilities.