HomeMy WebLinkAbout2018-09-25 CC Packet Enclosure Oak Park Heights
Request for Council Action
Meeting Date September 25a',2018
Time Required: 5 Minutes
Agenda Item Title: ISD 834—Conditional Use Permit Amendment—Garage Placement 5701
Stillwater Blvd N.
Agenda Placement New Business
Originating Department/Request a Johnson,City Administrator
Requester's Signature
Action Requested Discussi/Possible Action
Background/Justification(Please indicate if any previous action has been taken or if other public
bodies have advised):
Please see the following from Scott Richards,City Planning Consultant
1. Staff Report dated September 6th,2018
2. Planning Commission Resolution(unsigned)
3. Proposed City Council Resolution
Page 111 of 142
T P C 3601 Thurston Avenue N, Suite 100
Anoka, MN 66303
Phone:763.231.5840
Facsimile: 763.427.0520
TPC@PIanningCo.com
PLANNING REPORT
TO: Eric Johnson
FROM: Scott Richards
DATE: September 6, 2018
RE: Oak Park Heights—Stillwater Area High School—Amended
Conditional Use Permit— Lacrosse Equipment Storage Building
TPC FILE: 236.02 — 18.07
BACKGROUND
Ricky Michel of the Stillwater Area Schools has made application for an Amended
Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow construction of a lacrosse equipment storage
building at the Stillwater Area High School located at 5701 Stillwater Blvd North. The
building will be 30 feet x 30 feet (900 square feet) and will be placed south east of the
stadium. The project does not require Design Guideline review.
The site is zoned 0, Open Space Conservation District in which the High School has
been permitted as a conditional use. Any changes to the site or the uses require a
CUP. The original CUP for the High School was approved December of 1991.
EXHIBITS
The review is based upon the following submittals:
Exhibit 1: Letter from Kristen Hoheisel—August 17, 2018
Exhibit 2: Project Narrative, August 17, 2018
Exhibit 3: Title Sheet and Site Plan (A0.0)
Exhibit 4: Shed Plan (A1.0)
Exhibit 5: Shed Elevations (A2.0)
Exhibit 6: Shed Building Section (A3.0)
Exhibit 7: Site Photos
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The letter from Kristen Hoheisel is found as Exhibit 1 describes the project.
Additionally, the project narrative found as Exhibit 2 provides additional detail.
Page 112 of 142
The project narrative indicates the following:
The Stillwater Area lacrosse teams use a variety of equipment for its practices, including
lacrosse balls, marker cones, pads, nets, storage boxes, water jugs, carts, and other
practice items. Currently all of its equipment must be hauled out to the field and back,
for every practice, from an overcrowded small storage area inside the school.
The proposed storage building is centrally located at the corner of the three main
practice fields and stadium, allowing the equipment to be quickly distributed and stored
close to its use. The HS Boys, HS Girls and Youth program is raising funds to construct
the building, at no cost to the school district.
Current and Surrounding Land Use
The proposed location is just south east of the stadium field, well within the interior of
the school property. To the north, trees and vegetation screen the building.
Residences south of the property line are also screened by a change in grade and
trees. Approximately 100 feet to the north is the service drive between the stadium
fields and practice turf.
Proposed Use
The proposed building will be used for athletic equipment storage for the Stillwater
lacrosse teams.
Architecture
The building will be a slab-on-grade, rock-faced concrete masonry building with
concrete aprons on each end and on one side. The building dimensions will be
approximately 30'x 30', with an 11'4"high masonry wall topped by an 8/12 gable. The
roof peak will be about 22'1" above slab elevation. It will have gray fiberglass/asphalt
shingles. The eves and facia will be painted cement-fiber or composite boards, with
8'x8' overhead garage doors side by side on the north side of the building. The end
walls of the gable will be natural gray, similar to an existing storage building to the west
of the stadium.
The building will have electricity, but no water, sewer or plumbing. There will be no
exterior light fixtures.
Signage
On each garage door, and area approximately 4x6 (26 square feet) may have Ponies
logo or Stillwater Ponies name, in red, white and/or black.
2
Page 113 of 142
Site Design
The site is located to best serve the fields and reduce visibility of the building from all
vantage points. It will be graded to ensure stormwater drains positively away from the
building in all directions.
Site Utilities
Power to the building will come underground from the nearest available source, likely
the existing school,site lighting,or the stadium area.
ISSUES ANALYSIS
Comprehensive Plan. The property is designated as School Facilities on the
Proposed Land Use Map of the Comprehensive Plan. The proposed addition of the
storage building at the High School will be consistent with this land use designation.
Zoning. The site is zoned 0, Open Space Conservation District in which the High
School has been permitted as a conditional use. Any changes to the site or the uses
require a CUP.The criteria found in Section 401.03.A.7 of the Zoning Ordinance must
be considered when reviewing a request for this type.
Conditional Use Permit The Planning Commission should consider the following
issues and impacts of the proposed project in making its recommendation.
The conditional use permit criteria, found in Section 401.03.A.7 of the Zoning
Ordinance,are found as follows:
1. Relationship to the specific policies and provisions of the municipal
comprehensive plan.
2. The conformity with present and future land uses in the area.
3. The environmental issues and geographic area involved.
4. Whether the use will tend to or actually depreciate the area in which it is
proposed.
5. The impact on character of the surrounding area.
6. The demonstrated need for such use.
7. Traffic generation by the use in relation to capabilities of streets serving
the property.
8. The impact upon existing public services and facilities including parks,
schools,streets,and utilities,and the City's service capacity.
9. The proposed use's conformity with all performance standards contained
herein(i.e., parking,loading,noise,etc.).
Comment: The use is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and in conformity with
present and future land uses. There should be no environmental issues or impact to
surrounding tenants or property owners. The building will be screened by existing
vegetation and change in grade. Traffic generation will not be impacted by the addition
3
Page 114 of 142
of this building. There is no impact upon public services and facilities. City Staff sees no
issues with the addition of the storage building as currently proposed.
Setbacks. The building will be setback approximately 170 feet from the south property
line. The building is well within any required set back lines.
Building Height. The building will be 16 feet 8 inches to the mid-point of the gable.
The Zoning Ordinance allows roofs to the mid point of the gable to not exceed 20 feet in
height.
Parking. Parking is not impacted by this building. No parking spaces are removed,
and no additional parking is required for a storage building.
Grading/Drainage/Utilities. The grading of the site to accommodate the storage
building and resulting stormwater runoff shall be subject to review of the City Engineer.
Valley Branch Watershed District approval was not required for this structure.
Lighting Plans. The narrative indicates there will be no exterior lighting on the
building. If any lighting is added it will need to comply with the provisions of the Zoning
Ordinance. The building will have electricity, with the power coming underground from
the school, site lighting or the stadium area.
Landscaping. There is no landscaping proposed for the building.
Mechanical Screening. There will be no exterior mechanical equipment required for
this building.
Signage. The project narrative indicates that each garage door may have a Ponies
logo or Stillwater Ponies name in red, white and/or black. The signs would be
approximately 24 square feet each. The signage is compliant with the Zoning
Ordinance but shall require a sign permit.
CONCLUSION / RECOMMENDATION
Upon review of the request for an Amended Conditional Use Permit to allow for an
lacrosse equipment storage building at the Stillwater High School located at 5701
Stillwater Blvd North, City Staff would recommend the project with the conditions as
follows:
1. Any signage proposed for the site shall be in compliance with Section
401.15.G of the Zoning Ordinance and will require a sign permit.
2. Any additional lighting proposed for the equipment storage building shall
be in compliance with Section 401.15.B.7 of the Zoning Ordinance.
4
Page 115 of 142
3. Grading and drainage for the site shall be subject to review and approval
of the City Engineer.
Pc: Julie Hultman
5
Page 116 of 142
+ + F 44J
• St ■ STILLWATER AREA HIGH SCHOOL
' Ar '. 6701 Stillwater Blvd. N. J Stillwater, Minnesota 55082
AREA PUBLIC SCHOOLS Tel: 651.351.8040 J fax: 661.351.8049
wwstillwaterschools.org
August 17, 2018
Eric Johnson
City Administrator
City of Oak Park Heights
14168 Oak Park Blvd. N.
Oak Park Heights, MN 55082
Dear Mr. Johnson,
The Stillwater Area Lacrosse teams use a variety of equipment for its practices, including lacrosse balls, marker cones,
pads, nets, storage boxes, water jugs, carts and other practice items. Currently all of this equipment must be hauled to the
field and back, for every practice, from an overcrowded small storage area inside the high school.
The District is partnering with the HS Boys, HS Girls, and Youth lacrosse program to construct a storage building for all
this equipment It will be centrally located at the corners of the three main practice fields and stadium, allowing the
equipment to be quickly distributed and stored close to its use. The HS Boys, HS Girls, and Youth lacrosse program is
raising funds to construct the building, at no cost to the school district.
The proposed location is just south east of the stadium field, well within the interior of the school property. To the north;
trees and vegetation screen the building. Residences south of the property line are also screened by a change in grade and
trees. Approximately 100 feet to the north is the service drive between the stadium fields and practice turf.
The building will be a slab-on-grade, rock-faced concrete masonry building with concrete aprons on each end and on one
side. The building dimensions will be approximately 30' x 30', with an 11 '4" high masonry wall topped by an 8/12 gable.
The roof peak will be about 22'1" above slab elevation and 16'8" to the midpoint of the gable. This is under the 17"
zoning ordinance. The masonry will be natural gray, similar to an existing storage building to the west of the stadium. The
building will have electricity, but no water, sewer, or plumbing.
The district believes that this storage building will provide the lacrosse teams with easier access to their equipment and
allow for more efficient practices and year around storage for their equipment.
If you have additional questions, please feel free to contact me at any time.
Sincerely,
, / 17 i
1 t c.
Kristen Hoheisel
Director of Finance for Stillwater Area Schools
CURIOSITY
Thrives Here
Page 117 of 142
. i
Project Narrative
8.17.18
RE:Design Review Application for proposed new Equipment Storage Building,Stillwater Area
High School,Oak Park Heights,MN
The Stillwater Area lacrosse teams use a variety of equipment for its practices,including lacrosse
balls,marker cones,pads,nets,storage boxes,water jugs,carts,and other practice items.
Currently all of this equipment must be hauled out to the field and back,for every practice,from
an overcrowded small storage area inside the school.
The proposed storage building is centrally located at the corners of the three main practice fields
and stadium,allowing the equipment to be quickly distributed and stored close to its use.The HS
Boys,HS Girls,and Youth Program is raising funds to construct the building,at no cost to the
school district.
Current and Surrounding Land Use
The proposed location is just south east of the stadium field,well within the interior of the school
property.To the north,trees and vegetation screen the building.Residences south of the property
line are also screened by a change in grade and trees.Approximately 100 feet to the north is the
service drive between the stadium fields and practice turf.
Proposed Use
The proposed building will be used for athletic equipment storage for the Stillwater lacrosse
teams.
Architecture
The building will be a slab-on-grade,rock-faced concrete masonry building with concrete aprons
on each end and on one side.The building dimensions will be approximately 30'x 30',with an
11'4"high masonry wall topped by an 8/12 gable.The roof peak will be about 22'1"above slab
elevation.It will have gray fiberglass/asphalt dimensional shingles.The eaves and fascia will be
painted cement-fiber or composite boards,with 8"x 8"overhead garage doors side by side on the
north side of the building.The end walls of the gable will be natural gray,similar to an existing
storage building to the west of the stadium.
The building will have electricity,but no water,sewer,or plumbing.There will be no exterior
light fixtures.
Signage
On each garage door,and area approximately 4-0 x 6-0(24sf)may have a Ponies logo or
Stillwater Ponies name,in red,white and/or black.
Site Design
Page 118 of 142
The site is located to best serve the fields and reduce visibility of the building from all vantage
points. It will be graded to ensure stormwater drains positively away from the building in all
directions.
Site Utilities
Power to the building will come underground from the nearest available source, likely the
existing school, sight lighting,or the stadium area.
Project Contact List
8.17.18
Tony Willger
Supervisor of Facility&Site Operations
Independent School District 839
1875 S. Greeley Street
Stillwater, MN
(651)351-8374
Tim Siegfried
Contractor
George Siegfried Construction
510 Perro Creek Drive
PO Box 84
Bayport, MN 55003
(651)275-1112
tim@siegfriedconstruction.com
Joe Dean
Architect
Studio 2d
3600 Kinship Green N
Stillwater, MN 55082
jsmpdean@gmail.com(651)239-8402
Page 119 of 142
:�. : - �#3
Stillwater Area High School Ft
DRAM=Men
0.14.E-4ID sr -D
Lacrosse Storage Shed
5701 Stillwater Blvd.
0
U
Stillwater, MN 55082 "
--- — — = m �
C L
;/ ` CU .
a) ;_' a+
/
y r. g --- _ = O
.el �/ r all — COMM 3 3
rD
•
mere +. n !i, ra I E1 //r5 \' �.II .i I' 40 1. �.,' i O
RECEIVED AUG 1 7 2018 N I I'"""' •- '_ ---W.-' . , .,�' Rc -44,_ • -s;;; =..
1111 )
//L. !" —_ i =R o mom, !. t I !C _3 0)
0 0 t•ic:1_ , . v III
Sheet index. ? 0
.cru t9s to �^ Ctpw B.4ra4.�SQ.1R.
to an[U .. .'-'•sda
•
A0.0 Title Shed&Site Plan
POLE
i1�i!_��i Ierby ,,, �. ,..
-
A1.0 Shed Plan ",' ..a..+ �' '—I jgid i`�'ii�'=---...F.;4111141 _®� to
A2.0 Shed Elevations4 ' .`� I I -ra " 1 i... :i iiir --, C D
O.
A3.0 Steed Suiting Section = �. '
LJ 1 L le 'PA!IE_1�- � -i' L; �_,_
®Cµ�1apy urauw
The gene hew been des4Pnd b meet or exceed p*Wwsion.l bullring hi..etn I ----. II?. J `= •�':.II ene;�
etender but reprep design only end hew not been produced by a loaned -_. r ..�- s fi .�„
emitted on engineer.Your plan may need to be metalled to corn My Mm 1ocel {. ' , t o
g but
n leMla
nd
requirements nend,.,net Wed eele.to rdRors,Wie scud _ _ ._: ."`� _._.. _.1 'rill � A0.0
vigineedng,energy codes,eeM and eWmk cordarxe,411dnp coda,zoning ero.aoc
requirements,ordinances end bulldog rnq.bt ote.l DO NOT MAKE ANY °un°;s:a__--" —. I.
WARRANTY,EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WITH RESPECT TO Ti*CONTENT OR I _ _
-
USE MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS INCLUDING FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.WARRANTYsur NOT UWE°TO ANY I SITE PLAN- 1:200 - ._.-_.._..__.
CO
N
N
O
0
A
IV
t
Z.
till 1+ U
gill* � 9 29059 NW JalemffilS ' a
1�'rl�.;�,1i1 N 'PM81aWeMIN4S I.0L9 ii a •
inhiPENS 1 i A ill .. T__i
„, f„;tl i Iooya$ 116!H easy�a}eMEI e6woaS essa e ! Studio I 1
Hilfilin
.�•., i :.L'a.:t .a ri•v•..t-...,.'!.� ... ,'u>r.: t
a
nYCSOIN ee .a s�os�r11u It
1. .>,l ilai: 11Ii -.4----i-...— --= i
Lc.
i
i
— — —— - -E,
, V1
;l 1J3 i il 1 FiriT 4
lif',-4.1 i ', ':'i: ) 1:
131 ;� ,,��,. ; ,,. —Y
eDMISMIMiinna I
..} ii___J
} M
Page 121 of 142
kr)
Ak.
a
1
-
f4 4/fin 11 c
; r : i " 9 38495 NW aalertir�i�S , �m C
��o cilli •
s ' gi: I 'PAI Je eMI,!1S 6015 5 f N
11:iirqI r.1 a pops qB!H eeN JalemlIRS a6eYo esso s I
:� ..
nig as studio .I
.Hoag = o AI
1131333310333311181133141319
. g 1 p , -_ _ _ _ _ _ -
11 II
\ a i -
/
ii7 . _,
th
R r" R
._
_-
_ , 4D
... ,
_ ,_ _ _ _
_ _
. , _—___ �1, -in ,
... . .
-_-- Iii - 1.1
u .Jfra I\
•A'
I 1
li
. .-- -- r- r- - ' 4E)
_ r
i
Page 122 of 142
Zbl.to£ZI 06ed
I,
uuu.uuuuuuus••u•uhh
[-_-_ ,,
[_.
__,4
--\1
,________
aq
qRI .1
—�___ .. ___ ,
r
i___. ,
..._L___
r
nil 11$ 1 g 118 ,11
11
w.
eosz: worm:
Wdol s sn�seStorage ;M !
i E SStillwater Area High School I
IC)" i 8 5701 Stillwater Blvd.
— a .? Stillwater,MN 55082
t
CI.07
- r '
4 r •r .. t
E� I 1 ! 1 m_.1"" 1 • s `i t
.1' _iai -,•,,, �r f• -a!y "(Ay ..'"1:114.1
�'a 4'4f ,tet r• ..•,i'`.t'ti• • {jam .,{`.
1 .0'3,4' 'ir 1 1 r• t r r ' ,,•}• It 4 •Z s• ; • tom'`'• ?'t` wa
_�,.tt .--,5-,..,,,,,i.
1r ry.„j'tr #IN, 4 ?r 1' { r :1t .,1 /1 v �l-"j• :441it. nr -• S ". 4
f .•, y t Ai 4 r r !',',.r� k':-r 1:ct r4r� 1ltl�,�s. r yy'.(...','4'
• t� r+ky 4/ ^ ft • ••,,k'? •fyl f,y. •s.4 0 .--•...;* • ' lt.. s.....,'� % 3.; +C.�� -1. `♦ �v ✓s i.
t• • ' .,•
{• 'tk er' Yr it ` .' `f"r I r.f! • ,, S/•�' 4..._,.. a, , ,1 i ' .r .I.• • v4 • - `;+ .1
4.j. t . " 'Ysr• r ,: - 4�/•". •1" J. \ .r�. tt�� ... S f .0'
• •.r ,r•-.. r <4v, a • ;. ., •s 3 N.
y11 r r, '• -
" 2,41;..... }r.�r'd it . •., A,r� •,
•
•
ft ` - ti•. - •t 1 ► - y p`3 1 II F jja�r- .,y it
it
a. �� � s •� •
5 :t- r .1•�v r.is,ta,A Pe il f•►•,1t,.
t 4 • (• et.. 7,1 '• y•
r%`Q7tt i -/ i
ft
r• ; y i 2 ,:�_.t11 --
iIi . 1
! ��s . t=om A. - •
� —
e
6IN� S( vrr\ UkJou
C
Page 124 of 142
4.1 .,-..1,
pp , , , , 1 , i ,
M •
,;( b --4: i 1'i i' It )' 1
4. L
' e-
rt0777,1;4 A , . . 44 .4 1 1 '
f'n , iii,W - -114 )141wiiik • _
frgirttontz. 1
.,,,il,A r . r',;1,(....,jiiiiiiii
lii=ri,Lull,'71,4..1 • " I °, ei `; 4.: 4110.14, ',-...,......,• Mt 4) •Ay,
- * \ • 1
!,,:l•
tie gooluerimummer,40
NEM
orrompreprolowimmienr.,70........, , , I t,
LIONOMMINSIMIIMIk, - - i • t ,
1 . -',4 • ,
U
..0.... •
. ,
•' '.!., ' * i---.4
, . 1 t
i' 1 -0;.'t•
•
• i't st . 4tr,..1' • '; ',,t's '1
, .
N),_._i' ‘ . • — -%; i 11 ' ' '
4 '
. . ' :I .. • ' ......‘ . .. -
i`i i .`'''' 1 '' 'k 4 .1 ,: ..,....f. f./.... .„:,
. .,,,. : 4i,- - .10.volifo.4 •. .1 te,„1 •-: 1 • ,-- -...:T.' ..'../C,66,...6,it,i. 0,• -.1. ' '•• •
,. -,Itt %,I.: 2c‘`" • l'i '``' . .. • , •s.: f , --;/'‘ -* ` '''. k liett,.. . "
ki,. , „ ,... , , . . _ . „, ., ! ,:,_: Lt,4„..,,...:,,,,,,..„,„k. , ti-,. ...e,1,%teluA ,;;i" '? .: , "'I;
. , . . _a ;,, pi 1-,i ., ,.,,:. ;.,1 ,1. 4it . ,..,A.,.. ‘,.q,,,,,,,p,-.,-. . .11.7-1"..1%f'....1t, ,,, „ ,. 41„•., '0' Vie
',..4.1. .•-", ;1, i:, .'et1! 7,t :tioi.11 , ..4;t ii - A.)!, 1,.,t ,, '-',;`,•9 f,. ,. -..",-..,
t • •Wnrs:,P.:g., 1 h•elt, ,,,V• IC i V-A-• .1.1 r ' '''-it giq 43 • • ' '•IY.‘"' i,.. •,itt ,?-..,lk '"•'!"4-'s' 'A f'•4
, , • .: ..1:,;.: 4,...,,, ' -0-‘;ikt ..,,;41 i ,j rt,...,,,, i . . 41s, .'. ? 7,,,,:.' -'' ' .".. 's ••t 4 , . .4 ik . e ) 1P,.., 4
1 • ) ,ka 4 1417 tlife.,k - ••• . ,y. -i', ?;'•k, . .t.2iLl- . 1 ilk ' 'y 1:-,:,:,,,IA...,___':4 , 4- 1,1%
,tyt),..4„.
,, • ;,..., „.4•0., ,,ty zt •,--,,,.. oik• 1;• -,,, ,k „kutt. 1•• ;p!4s. Op, I:r _,.- if,Ili:: '' 434/Yr.. 41. 'IL-•I- . . ,,, ... 71.,,.L. 1,ift
ail,'fit!' 4, 1 ..4.,'' ''' 4 1 it ‘f.'.:,c.J 7:;= -r,•.•.. ”, •,::;,!Air:v.1.1'..ei--.....'1.....,.. r, -,u_ ;.',,....4v f,tit:
111,',". 'I : 1,k,..ito is,' • .,4,•4-.) ., 4,.p.,.. v.t. '. . Tt.r- .1,A 41,te 'w.
1:'•• \At i • ,,it,r;.:_,of.,:, ' is: -,, '. '; '•ef Ir.': ,t. , , Z 104 ._ 0'‘PAD, . ;..;,.. Jr:I. : ,,-. --, ' ', 4,
1
li: ' ,f"'• ,1`,1 !A' 1.*'' '4'),.- 'A1/4 • . kt-,;,*' i: .- i r •" !..•`• ,:,.Z.4 •'. ./7 PP ,,A4Pq. 1/$':1 $ K•'•6014 '..** a . -*
" ''‘j'•j.‘:' .. 4 1i7,'1;4 ••i• -,1 itIllit•kffr- '.''' 1 • . . 11 )04--. / 7 .4 ).•;,4i,71,.it--1,1 .... Tie rt . : . - J-.'• `titf----,
,(
''‘ f• 4.14'.' :°-,; /4,11,i-Vri"J
if ; A' I),ii.i . ,..',. f• --%irc- z ) 1 41.' • .4 A "I' ' i . 'Pl.--L-•94e : .itY, r 1 - ,-".• -, . ...4.... , .-..
•::',, . • ..,,t .0.,,„ir.,% .., - .•• f.% - ,••, -1 • , kite• ) • • - A 44*411.• ,,,.,. ' .--".1 ,:"^i r.„,;'.*4.•-- , ".-`..,A it-:-*Ai ' -. t'ei,
1 t • p.4 1-' •1 r*'.,j' A.,.( 4;t.,.4 -;. iii,:• . t • zt....11,(Itt,t,....-.4„,,„ ,I I
.--\ t' - - • . -14,- ', - ,. .... P...,• ' .0..:c . t .- : - jo,--w( • lf . - acket• '''.W N.,* .--;;:-4 t-' " • --f r r,.-A:,-
l',• . --'; t r':4.4. - ,:- "-,114'-'1-e10,4."7 ol' .' -',,r4t-***-- ,',.,.'tkl:. 3" ..." e *.* • --di'
‘. A' %-• ''' 1 ---;.'01
' - *0 • t . '4 :!-'‘ W,'",, k,..-4: [3,41:,i.;,,'I'i 6$.;,.!;; f.,Vit„,1 ,•r 11,2,,Ii''. CW.1, %Z..'"vt '- i; W 44‘ , -....., se" ,•'..:'-''.....
1 4, i'' .. ! . , il•'-, ,, .„,-„.- -., , iic.-... f-,,,i....-,•:;:d
t et, . 0 ,..a..46,_ 4 1,;. . i , ,. ,104.4-4. -.,.. •, ,...1„.....,
A
,..„.::_,... s.,.. 1. .. .41 .. .Fisf.,A.- .4..).; 44-.-L ',frit',.,.. 4111' '' e ' °':,11k1 r.-- 1 '4 -..--4 ; 1-. , :•-_,,,,„,-, -' Irk,47,,,,„„,._ *ip-''',:,.. .•iii,
4
r.'::.;,,40.1.4t 4' 414..,t, 1_it ,,y.lc: fii, , ,Ic..-..;-.--.i \t4.,ii, ,,-f cl ..;„:a0
tv.
Jar,...,..e;..t ..;41_,;‘,.: ri;oc. ‘i A ‘..!1#4 I. ‘ t OrAtk:\'..le•';' -1.: . •.. ".**4 .‘
44
tCy477 r„ - ( -- i 4:: c,Rit,;- Z.t1-40t,,,11,ry.•rt/4. r t, I.,.t •j, „t6t, A''••t tif Ai•Ple,tY r As 1 i , I
A • •-i Cr ' '','N4 .•
. .,‘4 . i..-•,. - i .,k".-1AyA 1 T1,.. 0 - .„ 4- .),,., _ . !J, : , , ' -- -,*( . .a. • 1,41 ;.-, _ .4 •
4, 4‘
„,,,, . ., ..., „ . . .,. ,,.,. , ,,..„,, ,,.,...,,As. • ..,•,„ .. ,„ 1„,,,. .0',. 01; .. o; .6 4. ;gyp '‘ t' ,. ie.'? ' ...);# I'
Lo 1- "I '. .r.4. 10i•h?-4.,, 1....,„ *..4
....Sr '' Or 1.-: '',. .4. - •••'''''• ' ,.', .1'•,i'.'"4- '%1.•,41,-;t j
,: . friA , / ell.; i f YA),J•it -1: ‘_.- . t .470.141•4y,,f,..- ,v,,,ii.. r .." - J.. .---: IA" . -44 • ,,, .,i - ..,:,, ,• , ,; 'I a. Zit. -, I,
;.' ' ' ' t• G.:!,•' ' '• 4: ,,A A • •l'ilm:-: ..,44,4- 11.,), . - .-• „: , - i. ^1'4' wkl.ir-• ' ' .4.'4. JA o- r
,1i 4
.1., .,..; •...„. ......,.., ,. ett. . . .,.:y....1 ,.... 4.1% t v,. ,,A ,01.1 • . .4).t.4..0., *':!I.i, '
,.P. i ..' :a ':- .,,, y t` ' ,:'" -'"•' ,* )h.i,s-4)1,Cikr ,_ t-. i--it, .!CoN Y V .,... ...1' 'At ... V. .. ''' V . ; • ' ' --'; V .
V' '1.t.,,iit''..,1' 4':. -' I -,,1-. t., ••;• -.:..t.,' .1-)4., L IS!'"%,%, .10." ; " i fs 1' 1' i'';,:tk..64.-.',4'..4. - k ' ..'-.-'1- -r• , ` ' . 4 1 •
‘ I -.I' ' y• . ' 1 •*
, •l'i. 1.:V40.7ki•-; .., 1,44,tif. ..,:i", 410 ' •;•.,'','1..1. ,f.fit#,.._- Vt,;., ;,,,.‘ . r,,,,t%' 9ti,...4 11.,,;; ‘. .,;,,,,S_,...,_;.:4. (1. it`,.: ..,A, ,i. 's .46: 4 , .' : * :
t A,
,,A,,- , , 4. ,..1 4 •It.; , I , ,.., ,A j, .
f
lk.,.. ;,. 1. ... •:.1-' .:TA,11, f•ii:',,5', - ,v.,--".:-; '.4.1 1, • , ‘. .,.1 ei;I, 4:„; ''•. -: I- -,t,.' ' .. `‘‘=„, -. .i.r i
4
..4
# is„,4,,1 • • i l''-, - */
4,1.‘ i,4 4 , ,, if.; ,,.:' _1‘,. i.P4i...,$ 4*.tit,,, -:,.-4 _. ,.•)-, ,r vith„. : .. %--. /i, ''''..„4 4,i— ,, - , ir
ti' -. *ijit, '-' .,.4341e,:,- -. .;,..71' •'-v' . e.,A. . .1.;.,;7N %9:1,.. ,.-- --;.,% ,. .4;%..:10,. ‘4.fr. -..„...4 -- . _Ate ,. i ,,,„,,,,,
i 4rNt
,), -.i t ' PiAra, lc-- -_„:"...,.. -j. *1- ' - . .'i . 4 --_ .4,i.,'1,,,i,... ..X 1,,` At ,.' i '..4-,,: 4' t•, 1.1p
A„ ,,,-„T,4, 17- •• • - :,41,1,,,, ye . :-..L.,-;.,1--.- j ojr.if 1 4 ''‘'•• S ?"4.. i ".-'... - 112A1,''
' I' • '''' • '' -.1- it•r;• ',-.:.''' ;/ 1,,, ,„ ,,,-:''jp, _,,i• ,virr „ ._ ,,,,- r...,,,,,...t..: eii .t5- _ . - ,.,.., ... , ..
At ...- .,
th..4.I rt.', it' • .• , .z ' )•• - '
C Qje-16, -Z eli-kt.CALi i\rdi-iLl
Page 125 of 142
...
- '. hvig "f• •••• *
.--- '1.--.1• ••• -Alt. 4:. -- l'AG7rhra • . .- -
, - ' .",0""S ‘.• 04, . i j!:.' •' t -11•..k '''.', •• - ..- ...:'T.-. .. • ,ii, .r.f"'• I -
t)16'•.:4" -.• ,(16: ;•.•• •, • '
4-
" ' " • • '• - ' 4*4P. t. • . ,i, 'Itt;V.,. *••••1476u6 *6006iteti -,--.. , ..
.• 1 ,• 1 •
a;(4•140-4';;:,. -- . 6 _.,-. '' ..,-. „.., • S. ••••• AL ..tp. ,:„. .
,...::-IF,'.....'4, .. , • t if--. i --4 „-1-•. , .':---..r.s ,,,,.."- '•. ,,. ..4.0,. ''''-4.. 1140014,:4 , •• • 4-i . • 3..... ..r.4.e..,
...,.., ..,..,
.. • ,...
.1,.. ,..4.,. -... . • , : .. .-4 . .>. 44, •, >"'"?'"r,- '''' ' - :45, - i:_,....,-
-,.. ir11 •
'a.- - , I, - -1..•"41.-..".
e,. • ... % ••• .:.tiiir • .• .4:Ar 44111F,. 4 -.1.f • 0 ‘i
.. -Agr. '' " . ''""*. . '1 . - •
-:-1 ..7.411. ',i'.e•4 ...'.1,',' , ..„'"•441101, - ,‘ ,,,:i.' •••••6%11. !,P. •
,'•.• I, •• ?.....9, -,- • ilisit,11^, • ••••• 1116,41-' ' • . v•i•
.0••i ,.. sto.,,, --,, ,-..y.„....- ,-,s4v,.. 1-44k7rit.,,,,Iiirt„,... •f.t6.. ?...t314,.c.,..4
•...
, 4• ,! ei- ,.,t. •
, • ..."6.... sk"IcAr.itN;; .. - 1-- ,''• •';-.--. • • . - . „
• 411111E4.'...-, eifir:' , . '_, -• .
' . ...
. r
... 9^•}F"'".. 41.4.4,h414C -.'
•P-•.‘ t•
1
idigr • 11 "' . 4110 ' • ' .' '-. . .1.
- • ' L....1,—',, , .r% .. • .. • ., . _ . . -- !..,'' -t: ' 'r
.1•:, _ .. ....A.,..,,, . 7,•,.!P , fe• •• ,771.1.kr, '..,1•'
sr•• -•••••:- V „,.rr i.
.... :1
.'..*:.;:;•' 'ir• •I". •Js•
• -.* •1* '14 -4•4 $0•4 . A. „1-4•4 .. ' ' .-..,*to--`46, • 141t.- . ..-:•:.•` 14'
t.,f. ...1,P•-• ' 40.!.1.4 .4* ,e-- ' Ilici • • .lioctvc:1-
• •, .:,.. -„,
.. r.
• - • .
1,k u r•••:, - l' .... . - • i .:,. ‘,j&*•*- •... It.* '''••t•i
4,,,, - 111111..... 4111110.1.,
•.
'''.....':1"'-_„.,• •‘•r1:14 ...)1..,:‘',...':'Ailet.06.. , •' j , s' _ , -1,,,11S1 .4.. .,,, • .
,, '1.1 -:-...--15r-I"AreS4. • l''',i ,,,_.- • •' - - •
:: r. .
ir.
Ilt •
„., _,7 , ,, , ..,44 .
• - Z eta ..•-$1,ilk . e'..''' i a " .„ -:.a
0• ..?' .
, , , nr., • IN '1, A-
'-.::;T;::, ,...";'t.-: .1,::.'!..•; )1'..".‘,.' — - • '.... 4%,,i'.. lik 41, ''' '7'' ' •.'
oiwst...! •.• N..,..‘ - • - , .
ii•,? .5..-. .: • •::,,..'" -. . . . ,X, • _ ., .s,. c.. ._ S' .4.111
.,.., , &.....„ ,IN• ••• • , _ .5,,,, •. * • 4• N., • •• 1 • 4.•• •
... L .•
al It • I, i „ . • ".t. .1, ' 4,; ... , 41.:
. ), , ,,,,, .,,,v, , - ,••••,- ..
. ..., • ,, , .e r• ,,,e 1." i ra 'I 2. ). ..• ,. ....;•-tro.".•1.:. 41,..:4 .. 447;:-'`
. • .......... 4 •N'•....,‘.., .,'•.• ,i.... v.
, ••„. ,,... .... ,..,-• , 1,,..,-. _. ,'(...,, , -Tc. r '4, :. ....." 45:?". t .,:. • ...4...' .
-' ilk*:";'•'", -:.''4' *'1•0?; • .tit-:.;, •.7: .', . :1, .. ..,' ..'. '. J , *-1-.•->s.".'.,, 4t:' . ...:* ":"1 .- - - -- .i, 4'i,„1
,
"'‘•°: - ''. '•st,•'•Okt -.1 '`. '••••• 1.4.7,. ...- .!. , .: r . .. • Att '• g -,, .''''-;1'.' , ,
-,,,,I .., • $04 4 • •••• !'4•' -,,, 1/4.4kt'-•ti.,-• -- :v. Av,• • ' -. 4 ir 4.* ye\la ile"-it '
- - . •- t ' - ‘ 1 . ...e,... . •.„.. _.. : ......, .„.,,,.._ .... ..,,......, ..„ . -,,. ,,k„. ii7- ,.•
.i,,A. '. • . 44: • ,it , ,' „1/0, • ,.,,,l'I'.;,i1.,•,%,;','," ',..." . , ) . ,1 117:;,'J (.131!•:): r
14
4 .•tri., ,• ?7,4,1,,.,1 1,...,41..1,,, .,..IA: t‘,.., • •, ..: s.'I . ..,' - ,. '-:4,-,4.- „ , .,-"L, .:;,.1. .,..,, . -rr."to.;'. ';' • •• 1, .#-• •'..!..;,:',-. ..',
IF.
4
s..:-. _'. - !*-*.:,:'•-, - r. , :: , ,.•,.... •". ', ,i ,,k ' ° ... vot„ i•''-.,A.CV .)•• '',0','',i:"i.14"-iiittik .14.F 4,i!•';.) ' .
4•4-...• ..,...• , .,,....15-..„1,.,..,;,‘ :,, • , .. i, .(•, ,..„. .1;i. r. ,... ..7
• .•,'" ' ..' .I:'''' ' ' ' •- '' 1.kgii,f,,'.' . /1;',.kr\+Cr.).‘: 4.' '01 t,'....
i
,,,,i,,,. ...„,,, ,. . .4 V,.,..7.' .7.0 . ' • _•', •4'1' 1.'44.414' ' •..,•1.., 414. • ,, ,,:y7'.1-2..i .'••s.IA I'' , ..• ,s -.• - '••• 7.--':---..,,.,
wk.': •N• '-'-.•VI ...:*. .,..`•"*.•- 4,,,.,,A . • . .. ....,, ,,,...; ,,,,.... ... • •, ,•• . .. , •.4"' '44..1:filit r ••• ,,, .,„•,i -11,..,. 1, , -, , ..:.e-....!,
,L 4,..,ti, xtr.e....- ..,,..t.ta. 1,:b..A I , - .Ilt ?,ii(4,0 ,f,t,., ...A, '', i ••,i..1,',‘. . ''•'
.. 44,tri.• ' 7. ...".," •.,,Tft.111•,.. ' - I"“C .1,17,-A..Si.. ,.:',,,, •rd,-r-..S„i. t .1, 1.;. ••••,k.:r; •,-. . i AS ...,'"ir -•,,"•• ' ' •..4..t. 7 •, ..4, . . ; 'i- 'E-'A:
; .t, 4,,,.4,0-,,,•,. ',. ,:i.c..? .f .. i:!tt •t*. .52...,-11:.`": "(.:i`''.tr' ...1.rt:,, lic •; ty,,4:,";.. .,,z 1! „ • •••g,4-
1
14.c- Tf..r:'•','.21-kel 'efc.-`,:.'J.'''.'4,$ - '• e. ...ti F:.'ff.,:v-:,'....",7- ' .4 '-'_•*_-..'-'• .t • I,
'' • • ??'',":','..teS',1i••••'• . . .g, ' .1 --: ',;.471,104t".- z •..-kki ' --- v• "*.••,'''`‘.-.-44-.' t.'. w'''5,1,V•0. . .-. IgN r•T:11..'t ..1.- „ .',.. • . -•-••_ -,,,
're, .'Itrt....$ ..,:it;'._ .'• 'rN.I.,4.4%tet"'"i.,-"."-. '.-,--• :- • .,-„ty• • ,kr "-..k• 7,•:-.-. ..? A-A.414 9ilt ...211 . 4.,...! ...„liPt!,•.. .,,,_.‘,44.7....oki, •'•:-.1,i,,,44S,,U,N,,.,,.
• i?"••:..;::•• ,•••1/1k1 "11:,' :I'.,;!t''.9',.' Vci,'•''-n-'s'j. Z.,,.",, 7.': -.•. „I''''''giv ' ,,,,,,, , ,...,....: . .1/4„4-.,...., . .4-il'"•••‘411'''' "'-'?".-./WI'7;''.r.
46.
,:,,,,..%,....vt......!..cc•:,4,4;,.....,..441.....z7,..:trik .-.I.. '1,`--..4.i-.": "m Rik ...,..', ""'" - Iv. . , ,. •,.•.,,,:,, ..,..i. . . • 4..,,:, •.„ ., .r. •,,,,e,_•...,. ...... .. .
A.,
..,,,....• . ., • .„ ..,. „„ .., • ,. •••,.. ,.... . • :„,,,,,,. . • .... •, . -.... ...- 4.-••• ,,,. • ,..4. ,•
, ..• , ...-..-,„$; ,.Y.."} tit., ' •`'...- .Z.1, 4- •= •,;,,I. .-'' . .!.,•rav:",...-.....r. .11.14.t . ..i,.. . . ..,.." , . -',. -....,:. , .?.• r, . ' • ..,• „ 1..
W .• •.t , - - '41,k;AA. ' •- :L. • 'rt.,' ' ..,„}:
' ..•,, ..,• • , :74. '-. • •, ,." '''',4• N'5i.;` .... • • . /...... .. ' - • 1 , . .. . ;•• i .. . .• .••••. '" • '5. .
g.
It .. • .. . ,
1`1. 1•"•11 ,„,1,1s."1 .40i.,!.' 4•N • -.L- - . .-•,- it 1.... • , )4g, ,••;, •
3....!.... .. .
,.. hed.• '. .). -
,..:4* . • ,....• .d.,i _ ., _... ,„...0.....„ . • - t..- ..._ 41,0. .....-
. •ts,.‘.
c---.- q..:40/..,..?7.471i ?sr• -sil --•.' , ,. ,f;r.•'tl.j" ,X. V.. • •• •:-' ''.i. . ., ••• •t''.-1.' , . - ' . t44-•,,'.Li ,••• i
. .ii.-...0 ...A. -1. : • iSk.,...“, '...'..s ., s•.., ...'
-**t-,....,%,,' t:4'',{1...•.;.-..... •9i.
I .- 4.• r _,,,o,.!'i •t. • '-..1, . "• ...... 'l'•', ; •..,,,i. ,... •Ils....,,N,.. (...,..----,., it-i....i... ;.--.....,
. .
,, .! •..•;-.1 .1 .4- •...
- . -.;;..-.,..;.b..,••..:2-I ‘• '-,?) '..• • -..,, ,, i..-,. ,..".4„i•S, •4,i0 - Vs.v. •
. • ..1„:•,•;,„;,..:„„ ..i - ,-,.. . .*:::.4..-..' -, -- .-;.-•..,...,i•-fri-44,t,44-4;-,‘•-••-14_.4.-.v•I •r.7;4 ..:„.--5 • . N n,
...k.W..:'.5, 0,r1,1•V.''',..;., f......'."' •• -.... . '1'.'5',Ir ' :.:,..!'".".'"'".'7.' ' . ,...: ',2_
• k,,.,iy • a 414 t .k..- ,. • 4 ..4•• - ,. r 4‘,L.•
, .
.V. t.
,. ' ...:•" ' ri".4 %-7:1-7trt- ,11 0 ".'' .'t-'.--"-•-•v... - .„. . -, • - ...i.:14.•••••,_ - . '.' wq..;.,'?„....,:-'.
`-. ....° 11-• '`i -••1 -• • i- k . .-••i -`'..^ ':.,4. '!it yr.%!'.,;.1'/'• -- ..' 2'....4y4-11:;:•'.',--••• -•-• ,V.---,,,. ..i...-, I; . ''. ..'re'''):,/:;....44:,-"!.'s'c.... ,,,''•...:'",'''•• '-'........':,4L4A..•yi.i. .•.',::iiit,.#4.1ai-,
i 4.-'' ' ' ' . . ir ' `,:‘,rti s. . ''' ' ,,'..-,-.1‘.`1.24iro ' .k. ;1*.''. . . "A•••:,'• :-'1,4%4..!‘..1-1*'-'''' • - ' ':. ..• 4 , • " •NI
.-r
.1. r!i-.4•4114,-,,
L'SY, - • ". .,,
" ' / rt, tip..• -_,•,:k.
rc•': - .
... ... .:. .. :,,,., ;4-e:. • .;4" .. • ' ."' .: ' • :. .•''',-, e' . ..'''''.' •411•4'; ' •'• '- - :. • • `. - ...-••
1..1•-•_.;•;, ..,..ii...f......:,..,L, - 1; .A ,,;,...-4,:0;::,.,t0,.. :. , , _4., ..,0.:,,,,t,. '' i • . 161:e.::A.-1"1 .,' •-''ie. •• 4,..,....A. . .4: .,.... '
?,,,,,irc. • ,,,-. .• . .,.:•, .,4 4,7!..t.)T4 ,,- .i.- '-.: :r.•... . ,i,, • .,:4...•1..;..„ E".....1 : ..„..,,
., ..
6r..eve. •'r ' • 1.."---:'‘ r44:1•V' '. 4,si.koi. •••..,,''Yle54,.. 44•„0.-tei-:,‘ ...-'•Aill.1,,f,":41,-L.'i,..,..4t•- •,:i• z.-i-,-, •;,;‘,..;',41,'N•,•Ii•74.,le r.......„•-•1:-*‘• ''.e•-- ••-:''''-i-
, : • -.1:r,' •- 'i' - ' '
y/.1`.L• 7-,V;.!*......r4-'''14,'• %ti.kiiJr.:t;„.tk .. ••••,,„„--. ,• . ',...:„...,.• .4':,..;:Al.e••;...,.• , --.•
. • 4i.ce.... : , . -..z :' 41 • .:;!: 4-;:,.,:r +...•,.. .. ; ...-..&,,,,,i4,.., "r sl:.• --r:•- -i- . •*..4.•' .,k4 '''•..'- 5. -.•.kit'••• .'1!•.. ., K'-*.**-----)it. . •'
. ' 14, '•••,4* - .'!4:-':' ; :•6''. '' 1 -.5 r .:... -... -.-- ...e.:•..1-4. ••4,-, ..L. . - 4,,,f, .4,,, •,..i....;:,,,,....-,,,•,. ..,.. Is, ,..c. ..•!.. 1,•...,..../
.•,::.••••", . . .. , •.4-4;... ., „'.' ., .,,,, ... --..../. . .. -.LOAN:44N ii• .. .,• .,0,0,.• . .i./ie...:. .M Niv,, wi/f," ..:" .,,e. i.,44, ',,._)v t.
'..
- -1.• -•r•-••• -•: . •'•,;. ...: .24,-4. Cl •r . ,.. ,, ,4..,,,t• .}.-, , v....Jo .. ,,,,i ,..-.,,,..•,,..k •.i.,-.•
. - -i, . "=1-*„..., , w.s,34,,44....;;;;: : . 1,.-:, Li „I., ,...._,... „4,;,_ 1.•• . • .... -
'!' ya, 41-1„.4..v.4.41,_o.1...i.•0......•...s-
(.._0(5_46:1-) eckL t(c)c^n"\ LI-KIL.
Page 126 of 142
' -.,..
. -1 •
A .'
t ,
.1 i_..,•• / ii,
, .N.
iktit
. .
.,
i
t„ VI 1
. • . - (Is... 11' t
A --• • -• . , .„, - .•
l'
v /".' • i •
. . ..—.. 1 9 1
, .
altam- - 1 .9,
(•-'
\\44 .
_ , •
9 .
. . 4 •
ii .....„.,
, 9
)
I t
,
li. ,1 ‘
, 1,,, ‹, .
J 6 .
• •••
/ •
,
1
/./.;- . i i •
i 1 '
/
I el
i l• .
_
r.., - ..0„,„; , 1, i f t . I it It if i
11 1 ; 1
1 .
-I- 1; , 1 i . .-- - • --
' -f f ? I —-
1 , r I .., -----,..7-... ,
' , if i l
. - 1 t
-v !...,1k14
V ,
...., ? _
t ,
1 A 4'.' I •
. .
1 „,--
- ,.1 i 1 iii ,
,-, -4 .,, .._ 1
. .-; -1,1-•
.5..... i',..?/:-,-71---,,q - i i /
I i I .....,
•
.. k 1,
mi. ,...S1:'1,, -- ' e '
.7.,.....0..,,,,--..12-t- , e ; 1 i i i
1 i ; i 1
I , , .
..,
40initilkatithe.L.t—, /
i I i
, .
. ,
i i
... .,
, ? i
I ii 111
' f -
g . .
NJ
' / i
I ' ,
. ,
_ .
. ,
. ,
i I 1 I i
il I I I • I, i •
1
, '..., f r I 1 I i I i 1
i / I I
, If 6 I i I (/ I !
,
6 • 1 f
I i r
,
.--,,,,: ,t ..- .. 1 1 ! i 1 i
- ,
- ..
, , t
t
1 1 I ,
i i r
? r
, t‘
....v1 I
•
_
i
• ' ' --r ' 1 I i
I 1 I , 1 1 te l'• I
•.-Iii-
‘ ,,f- . , i ;- i I t - r 1 I
... .,.. tt ...
5. f , g .
• 1 . . . . • I ,...
I
•1'%.
. i
i 'r/
__,_. —
_ .___
.-- — .,----- — ..-- —
I ..
‘ ,
, .
. ,
. 1
1•4, ' ! t
I. i )
i .I
\\
$ • . .
, 7. • .1
/ • It i i t .
. i
lk
,V44,,,,`•!:''
k.' ..,...,, .1,1 „.t,••• . g / .
6 i 6
"%', r; 1 ?
'" 1 .
• L 1. •i. 1. • t,
. t.• I•
,
-,ekti-VO 7 t
) ,
. . r k• -)
- i ., ., , v•
• '''-.W A.-z.. ., ...?..' , !
\ . .. ., •t_ •
so ' -
... ,
, --
.$
,...
1.
• .•
.
•.1. •
, *i.1 .-, ' I,. f t,
4
i . -". 1
• ti /
I •
. - 1 . .,- ,. k
:I 4 . • ,
ii. , LI •
. : 1 : •
,•
, .
, ... i
s
,
.
1 i•, L. . . .1 •5t.
/ 1,
• . r
r
t
• . i
t .• .
• . , f.• -._ ..
i •,,,, ..., , ,.. t
,
. •
I mt
\,...,\ \ „.
3 '
r
1,-- - .
,
..
,
+ k
'...k,
,,, .... - r
. . .- ..
.. .
. i
f.: v: 7Page 127 of 1 142
.,.! • Oitc - ; 7,--„, ,,
( -,,
f
A RECOMMENDING RESOLUTION
OF THE
PLANNING COMMISSION
CITY OF OAK PARK HEIGHTS
WASHINGTON COUNTY,MINNESOTA
A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING FINDINGS OF FACT AND
RECOMMENDING TO THE CITY COUNCIL THAT THE
REQUEST BY THE STILLWATER AREA PUBLIC SCHOOLS,ISD
834,FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW
CONSTRUCTION OF A 900 SQUARE FOOT LACROSSE
EQUIPMENT STORAGE BUILDING SOUTHEAST OF THE
STADIUM AT THE STILLWATER AREA HIGH SCHOOL
LOCATED AT 5701 STILLWATER BOULEVARD NORTH SHOULD
BE APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
WHEREAS,the City of Oak Park Heights has received a request from the Stillwater
Area Public Schools,ISD 834,for a Conditional Use Permit to allow construction of a
900 square foot lacrosse equipment storage building southeast of the stadium at the
Stillwater Area High School,located at 5701 Stillwater Boulevard North;and after
having conducted a public hearing relative thereto,the Planning Commission of Oak Park
Heights makes the following findings of fact:
1. The real property affected by said application is legally described as
follows,to wit:
SEE ATTACHMENT A
and
2. The applicant has submitted an application and supporting documentation
to the Community Development Department consisting of the following items:
SEE ATTACHMENT B
and
3. The property is zoned 0,Open Space Conservation District. The subject
property requires a conditional use permit for changes to the site or uses. The addition of
the equipment storage building is considered a change of use;and
4. The storage building will comply with all setbacks,building height and
other performance standards of the Zoning Ordinance;and
Page 128 of 142
5. City staff prepared a planning report dated September 6,2018 reviewing
the request; and
6. Said report recommended approval of the Conditional Use Permit subject
to the fulfillment of conditions; and
7. The Planning Commission held a public hearing at their September 13,
2018 meeting,took comments from the applicants and public, closed the public hearing,
and made the following recommendation:
NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED BY THE PLANNING
COMMISSION FOR THE CITY OF OAK PARK HEIGHTS THAT THE
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDS THE FOLLOWING:
A. The application submitted by the Stillwater Area Public Schools, ISD 834,for a
Conditional Use Permit to allow to allow construction of a 900 square foot lacrosse
equipment storage building southeast of the stadium at the Stillwater Area High School
located at 5701 Stillwater Boulevard North and affecting the real property as follows:
SEE ATTACHMENT A
Be and the same as hereby recommended to the City Council of the City of Oak Park
Heights for approval with the following conditions:
1. Any signage proposed for the site shall be in compliance with Section
401.15.G of the Zoning Ordinance and will require a sign permit.
2. Any additional lighting proposed for the equipment storage building shall
be in compliance with Section 401.15.B.7 of the Zoning Ordinance.
3. Grading and drainage for the site shall be subject to review and
approval of the City Engineer.
Recommended by the Planning Commission of the City of Oak Park Heights this 13th
day of September 2018.
Timothy Freeman, Chair
ATTEST:
Eric A. Johnson, City Administrator
2
Page 129 of 142
ATTACHMENT A
Conditional Use Permit Amendment
Stillwater Area High School(ISD#834)
Lacrosse Equipment Storage Building
Washington County Parcel Number: 06.029.20.41.0002
Legal Description:
Beginning at the Northeast corner of the South 496.00 feet of said Northeast Quarter, as
measured at a right angle to the South line of said Northeast Quarter; thence South 88 degrees 45
minutes 42 seconds West, assumed bearing, along said North line 2342.42 feet to the center line
of Trunk Highway 5, as presently located and traveled; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12
seconds East along said center line 536.45 feet; thence South 55 degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds
East 270.00 feet to the North line of the South 771.07 feet of said Northeast Quarter, as measured
at a right angle to said South line; thence North 88 degrees 45 minutes 42 seconds East along
said North line 1800.79 feet to the East line of said Northeast Quarter; thence South 02 degrees
00 minutes 03 seconds East along said East line 275.07 feet, more or less, to the point of
beginning, containing 14.79 acres,more or less.
Subject to Trunk Highway 5 along the Northwesterly 78.00 feet thereof and subject to
restrictions and easements of record.
Together with an easement for the purposes of construction, installation,maintenance and repair
of utilities under, upon and over the Easterly 30 feet, as measured at right angles to the Easterly
line thereof of the following described property:
That part of the Northeast Quarter of Section 6,Township 29 North,Range 20 West,Washington
County, Minnesota, described as follows:
Beginning at the Northeast Quarter of the South 771.07 feet of said Northeast Quarter, as
measured at a right angle to the South line of said Northeast Quarter;thence South 88 degrees 45
minutes 42 seconds West,assumed bearing, along said North Line 1800.79 feet; thence North 55
degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds West 278.00 feet to the center line of Trunk Highway 5, as
presently located and traveled; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12 seconds East along said
center line 1185.28 feet to the South line of the North 801.66 feet of said Northeast Quarter as
measured at a right angle to the North line of said Northeast Quarter;thence North 89 degrees 54
minutes 56 seconds East along said South line 1383.19 feet to said East line of the Northeast
Quarter; thence South 02 degrees 00 minutes 03 seconds East along said East line 1017.03 feet to
the point of beginning, containing 41.20 acres,more or less.
Subject to Trunk Highway 5 along the Northwesterly 78.00 feet thereof and subject to
restrictions and easements of record.
Page 130 of 142
AND
That part of the West Half of the Southwest Quarter of Section 5, that part of the
Southeast Quarter of Section 6, that part of the Northeast Quarter of the
Southwest Quarter of Section 6, that part of the Southeast Quarter of the
Northwest Quarter of said Section 6 and that part of the Northeast Quarter of said
Section 6 all in Township 29 North, Range 20 West, Washington County,
Minnesota,described as follows:
Commencing at the Southeast corner of said West Half of the Southwest Quarter of Section 5;
thence North 01 degree 48 minutes 09 seconds West, assumed bearing, along the East line of
said West Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 1733.20 feet to the point of beginning;
thence South 89 degrees 50 minutes 41 seconds West parallel with the South line of said West
Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 1325.39 feet to the Westerly line of said West Half
of the Southwest Quarter; thence South 88 degrees 54 minutes 15 seconds West parallel with the
South line of said Section 6 a distance of 3332.47 feet to the center line of Old Trunk Highway
212 as located and traveled in 1923; thence North 33 degrees 26 minutes 30 seconds East along
said center line 996.03 feet; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12 seconds East along said
center line 100.41 feet to the North line of said Northeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter;
thence South 88 degrees 45 minutes 42 seconds West along said North line 3.69 feet to the center
line of Trunk Highway 5 as presently located and traveled; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes
12 seconds East along said center line 609.44 feet to the North line of the South 496.00 feet of
said Northeast Quarter; thence North 88 degrees 45 minutes 42 seconds East along said North
line 2342.42 feet to the East line of said Northeast Quarter; thence South 02 degrees 00 minutes
03 seconds East along said East line 496 feet, more or less, to the Northwest corner of said West
Half of the Southwest Quarter; thence North 89 degrees 46 minutes 17 seconds East along the
North line of said West Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 1324.32 feet to the Northeast
corner of said West Half of the Southwest Quarter; thence South 01 degree 48 minutes 09
seconds East along said East line of the West Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 910.86
feet to the point of beginning.
EXCEPT that part thereof being the tract described in Document No. 468927 recorded and on
file in the office of the County Recorder, Washington County, Minnesota.
Subject to Trunk Highway 5 along the Northwesterly line thereof.
The total area of this parcel is 118.00 acres,more or less.
Subject to restrictions and easements of record and subject to a drainage and ponding easement
over that part of the Northeast Quarter of Section 6, Township 29 North, Range 20 West,
Washington County, Minnesota lying Easterly of the Easterly right of line Trunk Highway 5
described as follows:
Commencing at the intersection of center line of said Trunk Highway 5, as presently traveled,
and the South line of the North half of said Section 6; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12
seconds East, assumed bearing, along said center line 288.78 feet to the point of beginning;
thence South 55 degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds East 85.00 feet thence South 11 degrees 42
minutes 48 seconds East 115.00 feet; thence South 84 degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds East
110.00 feet; thence North 00 degrees 21 minutes 42 seconds East 248.93 feet; thence North 55
degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds West 125.00 feet to said center line; thence South 34 degrees 17
minutes 12 seconds West along said center line 180.00 feet to the point of beginning, containing
0.71 acres, more or less. Page 131 of 142
AND
Outlot 'A' and Outlot `B', Kern's Education Addition, as platted and on file and of record in the
Office of the County Recorder of Washington County,Minnesota.
Page 132 of 142
ATTACHMENT B
-
Conditional Use Permit Amendment
Stillwater Area High School (ISD#834)
Lacrosse Equipment Storage Building
Application Materials
• Application Form
• Fees
• Plan Sets
• Written Narrative and Graphic Materials Explaining Proposal
• Mailing List from Washington County(350'/150' from subject property)
• Proof of Ownership or Authorization to Proceed
• Property Tax Statement(s)/Legal Description(s)
Planning Commission Public Hearing& Recommendation: September 13,2018
Required Approvals: CUP Amendment
City Council 4/5
Conditional Use Permit-Lapse of Approval:
Unless the City Council specifically approves a different time when action is officially taken on
the request, the conditional use permit shall become null and void twelve(12)months after the
date of approval,unless the property owner or applicant has substantially started the construction
of any building, structure, addition or alteration, or use requested as part of the conditional use.
An application to extend the approval of a conditional use permit shall be submitted to the
Zoning Administrator not less than thirty(30)days before the expiration of said approval.
(401.03.C.4.a and b)
CUP Amendment:
An amended conditional use permit may be applied for and administered in a manner similar to
that required for a new conditional use permit. Amended conditional use permits shall include
reapplication for permits that have been denied,requests for substantial changes in conditions or
expansions of use,and as otherwise described in City of Oak Park Heights Zoning Ordinance
401. (401.03.C.5)
Page 133 of 142
RESOLUTION NO.
CITY COUNCIL
CITY OF OAK PARK HEIGHTS
WASHINGTON COUNTY, MINNESOTA
A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING FINDINGS OF FACT AND
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL THAT THE
REQUEST BY THE STILLWATER AREA PUBLIC SCHOOLS, ISD
834, FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW
CONSTRUCTION OF A 900 SQUARE FOOT LACROSSE
EQUIPMENT STORAGE BUILDING SOUTHEAST OF THE
STADIUM AT THE STILLWATER AREA HIGH SCHOOL
LOCATED AT 5701 STILLWATER BOULEVARD NORTH BE
APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
WHEREAS,the City of Oak Park Heights has received a request from the Stillwater
Area Public Schools, ISD 834, for a Conditional Use Permit to allow construction of a
900 square foot lacrosse equipment storage building southeast of the stadium at the
Stillwater Area High School, located at 5701 Stillwater Boulevard North; and after
having conducted a public hearing relative thereto, the Planning Commission of Oak Park
Heights recommended that the application be approved with conditions. The City
Council of the City of Oak Park Heights makes the following findings of fact and
resolution:
1. The real property affected by said application is legally described as
follows,to wit:
SEE ATTACHMENT A
and
2. The applicant has submitted an application and supporting documentation
to the Community Development Department consisting of the following items:
SEE ATTACHMENT B
and
3. The property is zoned 0, Open Space Conservation District. The subject
property requires a conditional use permit for changes to the site or uses. The addition of
the equipment storage building is considered a change of use; and
4. The storage building will comply with all setbacks,building height and
other performance standards of the Zoning Ordinance; and
Page 134 of 142
5. City staff prepared a planning report dated September 6,2018 reviewing
the request; and
6. Said report recommended approval of the Conditional Use Permit subject
to the fulfillment of conditions; and
7. The Planning Commission held a public hearing at their September 13,
2018 meeting, took comments from the applicants and public, closed the public hearing,
and recommended that the application be approved with conditions.
NOW,THEREFORE,BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL FOR
THE CITY OF OAK PARK HEIGHTS THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVES
THE FOLLOWING:
A. The application submitted by the Stillwater Area Public Schools, ISD 834, for a
Conditional Use Permit to allow to allow construction of a 900 square foot lacrosse
equipment storage building southeast of the stadium at the Stillwater Area High School
located at 5701 Stillwater Boulevard North and affecting the real property as follows:
SEE ATTACHMENT A
Be and the same as hereby approved by the City Council of the City of Oak Park Heights
with the following conditions:
1. Any signage proposed for the site shall be in compliance with Section
401.15.G of the Zoning Ordinance and will require a sign permit.
2. Any additional lighting proposed for the equipment storage building shall
be in compliance with Section 401.15.B.7 of the Zoning Ordinance.
3. Grading and drainage for the site shall be subject to review and
approval of the City Engineer.
Approved by the City Council of the City of Oak Park Heights this 25th day of
September 2018.
Mary McComber,Mayor
ATTEST:
Eric A. Johnson, City Administrator
2
Page 135 of 142
ATTACHMENT A
Conditional Use Permit Amendment
Stillwater Area High School (ISD#834)
Lacrosse Equipment Storage Building
Washington County Parcel Number: 06.029.20.41.0002
Legal Description:
Beginning at the Northeast corner of the South 496.00 feet of said Northeast Quarter, as
measured at a right angle to the South line of said Northeast Quarter;thence South 88 degrees 45
minutes 42 seconds West, assumed bearing, along said North line 2342.42 feet to the center line
of Trunk Highway 5, as presently located and traveled; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12
seconds East along said center line 536.45 feet; thence South 55 degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds
East 270.00 feet to the North line of the South 771.07 feet of said Northeast Quarter, as measured
at a right angle to said South line; thence North 88 degrees 45 minutes 42 seconds East along
said North line 1800.79 feet to the East line of said Northeast Quarter; thence South 02 degrees
00 minutes 03 seconds East along said East line 275.07 feet, more or less, to the point of
beginning, containing 14.79 acres,more or less.
Subject to Trunk Highway 5 along the Northwesterly 78.00 feet thereof and subject to
restrictions and easements of record.
Together with an easement for the purposes of construction, installation, maintenance and repair
of utilities under, upon and over the Easterly 30 feet, as measured at right angles to the Easterly
line thereof of the following described property:
That part of the Northeast Quarter of Section 6, Township 29 North, Range 20 West,Washington
County, Minnesota, described as follows:
Beginning at the Northeast Quarter of the South 771.07 feet of said Northeast Quarter, as
measured at a right angle to the South line of said Northeast Quarter; thence South 88 degrees 45
minutes 42 seconds West, assumed bearing, along said North Line 1800.79 feet; thence North 55
degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds West 278.00 feet to the center line of Trunk Highway 5, as
presently located and traveled; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12 seconds East along said
center line 1185.28 feet to the South line of the North 801.66 feet of said Northeast Quarter as
measured at a right angle to the North line of said Northeast Quarter; thence North 89 degrees 54
minutes 56 seconds East along said South line 1383.19 feet to said East line of the Northeast
Quarter;thence South 02 degrees 00 minutes 03 seconds East along said East line 1017.03 feet to
the point of beginning, containing 41.20 acres,more or less.
Subject to Trunk Highway 5 along the Northwesterly 78.00 feet thereof and subject to
restrictions and easements of record.
Page 136 of 142
AND
That part of the West Half of the Southwest Quarter of Section 5, that part of the
Southeast Quarter of Section 6, that part of the Northeast Quarter of the
Southwest Quarter of Section 6, that part of the Southeast Quarter of the
Northwest Quarter of said Section 6 and that part of the Northeast Quarter of said
Section 6 all in Township 29 North, Range 20 West, Washington County,
Minnesota, described as follows:
Commencing at the Southeast corner of said West Half of the Southwest Quarter of Section 5;
thence North 01 degree 48 minutes 09 seconds West, assumed bearing, along the East line of
said West Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 1733.20 feet to the point of beginning;
thence South 89 degrees 50 minutes 41 seconds West parallel with the South line of said West
Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 1325.39 feet to the Westerly line of said West Half
of the Southwest Quarter; thence South 88 degrees 54 minutes 15 seconds West parallel with the
South line of said Section 6 a distance of 3332.47 feet to the center line of Old Trunk Highway
212 as located and traveled in 1923; thence North 33 degrees 26 minutes 30 seconds East along
said center line 996.03 feet; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12 seconds East along said
center line 100.41 feet to the North line of said Northeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter;
thence South 88 degrees 45 minutes 42 seconds West along said North line 3.69 feet to the center
line of Trunk Highway 5 as presently located and traveled; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes
12 seconds East along said center line 609.44 feet to the North line of the South 496.00 feet of
said Northeast Quarter; thence North 88 degrees 45 minutes 42 seconds East along said North
line 2342.42 feet to the East line of said Northeast Quarter; thence South 02 degrees 00 minutes
03 seconds East along said East line 496 feet, more or less, to the Northwest corner of said West
Half of the Southwest Quarter; thence North 89 degrees 46 minutes 17 seconds East along the
North line of said West Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 1324.32 feet to the Northeast
corner of said West Half of the Southwest Quarter; thence South 01 degree 48 minutes 09
seconds East along said East line of the West Half of the Southwest Quarter a distance of 910.86
feet to the point of beginning.
EXCEPT that part thereof being the tract described in Document No. 468927 recorded and on
file in the office of the County Recorder, Washington County, Minnesota.
Subject to Trunk Highway 5 along the Northwesterly line thereof
The total area of this parcel is 118.00 acres, more or less.
Subject to restrictions and easements of record and subject to a drainage and ponding easement
over that part of the Northeast Quarter of Section 6, Township 29 North, Range 20 West,
Washington County, Minnesota lying Easterly of the Easterly right of line Trunk Highway 5
described as follows:
Commencing at the intersection of center line of said Trunk Highway 5, as presently traveled,
and the South line of the North half of said Section 6; thence North 34 degrees 17 minutes 12
seconds East, assumed bearing, along said center line 288.78 feet to the point of beginning;
thence South 55 degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds East 85.00 feet thence South 11 degrees 42
minutes 48 seconds East 115.00 feet; thence South 84 degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds East
110.00 feet; thence North 00 degrees 21 minutes 42 seconds East 248.93 feet; thence North 55
degrees 42 minutes 48 seconds West 125.00 feet to said center line; thence South 34 degrees 17
minutes 12 seconds West along said center line 180.00 feet to the point of beginning, containing
0.71 acres, more or less. Page 137 of 142
AND
Outlot'A'and Outlot'B',Kem's Education Addition,as platted and on file and of record in the
Office of the County Recorder of Washington County,Minnesota.
Page 138 of 142
ATTACHMENT B
�E.
Conditional Use Permit Amendment
Stillwater Area High School(ISD#834)
Lacrosse Equipment Storage Building
Application Materials
• Application Form
• Fees
• Plan Sets
• Written Narrative and Graphic Materials Explaining Proposal
• Mailing List from Washington County (350'1150' from subject property)
• Proof of Ownership or Authorization to Proceed
• Property Tax Statement(s)/Legal Description(s)
Planning Commission Public Hearing&Recommendation: September 13,2018
Required Approvals: CUP Amendment
City Council 4/5
Conditional Use Permit-Lapse of Approval:
Unless the City Council specifically approves a different time when action is officially taken on
the request, the conditional use permit shall become null and void twelve(12)months after the
date of approval,unless the property owner or applicant has substantially started the construction
of any building, structure, addition or alteration, or use requested as part of the conditional use.
An application to extend the approval of a conditional use permit shall be submitted to the
Zoning Administrator not less than thirty(30) days before the expiration of said approval.
(401.03.C.4.a and b)
CUP Amendment:
An amended conditional use permit may be applied for and administered in a manner similar to
that required for a new conditional use permit. Amended conditional use permits shall include
reapplication for permits that have been denied,requests for substantial changes in conditions or
expansions of use,and as otherwise described in City of Oak Park Heights Zoning Ordinance
401. (401.03.C.5)
Page 139 of 142
THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
,.r
Page 140 of 142