HomeMy WebLinkAbout2007-05-08 CC Meeting Packet Enclosurey J•
—
}
v�
il� ys�
Oak Park Heights
Request for Council Action
Meeting Date Ma 8"' 2007
Time Required,
Minutes
.Agenda Item Title: Fencing - Bayp Substation w _ cel ELier
Agenda Placement New Business
Originating DepartmentlReq tq• - 4 ri bnson Citv Administrator
Requester's Si gnature
A ction requested A � - ove �� en in Plank Condit
Background /Justification (Ple se ndicate if any previous action. has been taken or if other public;
bodies have advised)
As the Council will recall, last summer the City required Xcel Energy to update the fencing and
driveway at the Baytown Substation, agjacent to Lowes. Specifically, the City asked that they install a
more aesthetically pleasing; wood :Fence and remove the chainlink / barbed wire and blacktop the
driveway. These improvements are to be installed this spring,
cel Energy has provided the enclosed fencing plans. Staff has reviewed them and found then to be
generally compliant with the City's Fencing Ordinance. Additionally, Staff is also recommending that
some additional landscaping; and screening be installed at the various point around the outside of the
fence to additionally soften the exterior.
The City's authority to require such fencing and screening, stems, from the Conditional Use Permit as
issued In 1990.
Pursua,Df to the then issued CUP, the City, may revoke this CUP and require that this substation be
removed as there has been a material change in the condition of the neighborhood since the 1990
issuance. However, at this time Staff is not recommending such action, rather only that appropriate
steps be taken to make the site more compatible with the surroundings, and which may be
accomplished by this new screening; an landscaping,
ecommendation' Approve the general concept of the enclosed fencing plan and regnxre that
additional landscaping 'Items he installed on the outside perimeter of the fence. Final design of
the fence and landscaping shall be subject to the final review and approval of the City Planner
and Arborist. The City may require more stringent rules on this fencing and landscaping
because of the existence of the CUP.
Attachments Copy of 1990 Conditional Use Permit
Fencing flans
Color photos of Similar Uses.
CITY OF OAK PAU, II fGHTS
WASHINGTON COUNTY y MI NH OO TA
gL WITIONAI, USE PERMIT
Sub, c t to €.Iie wmis and conch I. o s •set fw tti herei p ,
the City of W Pd T* kci ights flervby graf) 0 coil 1 i ti ona1 use penni �_ for
(t x
laic pe t t i S for tilp Cpl l ow ng daW i bI~ pro r ,
i sl t)je C of Ook P ark 1101911 L� i �Wd IWQI3 COST JY y Mi r1l) ,Qs (ita
1'i f, €VLSI` 340. 00 1.- 00 i �f ? ff hS I" t f 3. i t'T fit" THE SOWN?
f 'l I: v[�I�'I'j1 5 50 , 0Q I €`:'' UI- T, €f: fJf�I:Tft €:I�ST QUARTER
OF THf` , ORIIff.AST � #t►t�' # €:!� 0 1: SECTI "' !a 1'���it�Sl��i' ?.9 fJ�)�'fff,
MN C - 2 0 (0I,ST, �(IASW NOTON f'[)tWTV, M 7 NNrS01'A, AS MEA &UREP AT h
P, 7 C 1i`1' ANGLE' To I' I:AS 1. A ND T1 N O R 1'f t L€`N€: O F S AID wORTH
Q UARTC. , R OF TIN' NORTHIAST Q UARTER.
di buns, � � ;S t^�i11 35 3Sst4ed S uUif:Ct tO th(.1 fol lwing
c onoi tI4ns: ..
4. of f eMi t. The City may ravo�e the get t fat i 0W-
ing a Public hearing under any of t herifol•l owing ' c;irc�,►1St r� es; t t
change - con di ti on of the ne l ghborhood•- whgr� tltr, f -... 0 .
tile te1'1315. o f 0o pv rm i L. The• peivi t is 4" Wi16il t i c(i 1 I Y to rms fla tad 'i if riA C
utilized.withill ore year of the dote of City CO"r -il ,)f;Proval
CrirliimL I)gpalt , vjplatiowof, the torm of psis r;oaditional
use per�iii t is •a crimi ti4l misdemeanor .
Dated �ov - - -- l - �1 90 -b
CITY o f OAK I'A RK BLIGHTS
r
BY* _.L—A -�- _
..�.. .
'ts Pay
�-
�.. tS mf1)18 t r
.,TATS OF MI NNESO•IA
COU11TY OF WASHINGION
s
The foregOitlg instrument was acknowledged before pie this and of , lq �c9 p by frank 0. Soff0er`f0dL, Mayor, n 1
La�dOrlt�FW115oii, C" ty Cler�C a7 � the City of Oak J 'ark �ti►i����ts, a I4�r�ne�o �.
mu;l i c i pal corpo ra Li orl , otl behalf of tha-corPMI-tlon-
NOTAG
,JUDY L HQLST
E� p t) COUNT Not R ub �t C
4" Vcp3r4 # -17.90
t)RAM'21) 13Y CI'T'Y Of" OAK I !'AIM 1We1G11q'S
14168 Nortli 5701
oak 'ark Hei.ghts, W4. 55089
i
MIM
MID
'AL
�. J< I T � .. 1 1 3 !�
t z = f r � � � -� � j � � �$ 11 t
66TH
-,S
d ------ -------
E
R'EFEFtt�NCE* fr r �i r� J 1 ��
IL
DIT
IC
kA
`� t f j r i r� i� �� �;�'!� __..���� f � � _ _ _ ..� f -� ; Y L _. �... �; -�`. .�� . � r 3
a. _�.1 �_ �, +.,j -�.� i -�-j -� 1�' � �;^-�"' ��• `�'•�' � _.... _�a�....., _._ ° . - ���ii1� `� L4 f -� � � i f�
i � �I %� � 1�' 'j�r'e.�..,..`.y_ .�. ei� - ,�` �f��Jl � �� rl � r r �.� �u • � ` 1S �
Z- J./.
2mif" it 0) IN.
t
fq
.
r' � it � � �' it =i •� �, M
V�
Z
ks A R " P A P
10
A 1 -6
7 V
m v- V g's-6
7,,
8 Pat
Co
KAN
1, ; V. qq 8 Ak Z' ;0
f p
I c
ILI t uy l ] X 8
1.9 . r
L I
r ) v
tn 0"', 29 y;: ,4, x v p
42 5. V '.
cn Z!
K
u-
RA
cn
Y'4
c p 0
P4 f-
ZI A
.. .........
__oz
- ---------------- -
-
Al
NMI
N O
O t
IN
tz
I N
NO
'h�ti r.I Y, :R':: �?w,.-. - ` 'i _' •i`•t'tF!
- ' ?� .:••- � `= i R ,s
Cl•y �� -1'.. ` • i r['' • . L i •- t o S ' • :Y� ,. •�•�ri••'S v� Si ~• • •f••d• � 1
i .�y ll is f • ?•:t:' y :f.' }?
;, Lam: [.rl .- * -- 1 . -�'.' ir.. ? { ii
' Y:•
Y ti!y�' : � }•• :S ; • 't %'.i . ti'I • . - i • .y
s _ f . �...
=
r7, •` .mot
s .; . �-• - s .,r.t' L .tr
' I' f{'!= r�ci'S;rS•,�LtLR,,,,�, ts�L•`_fz.•1` 'g
pSgj W. S;Sti ' .b�, : ��r}'Y •7t1� :•�: t �:1
r =: ,•� . \.5sfti i ,;. =;•fir- Sca Sj
\ 5a ..: •.
"'ri'4+�sA.' -\'�' _ "i", - F - • • - '..I. �:IL;gR
,\y {:.t ti,,- ,w l. ti <;Gt,�.. w�_ .%L:r,• f
r 1 : s cs1, R • z _ ` =" ' +
a - • 5
y +' r r. 5 t
t :r?
•{
L
-' /
1 f. �r I Y { A !� - tir�y`Lif'� \!VH}�.'S �LSF -:v a n,Zt � x
. , i' c"r
5' !• f•i
l•
• .ti
:r . 1
L+
'ti'
f
�_
is
K
• •i •tit
y
I..
ti '
y � sy � � s.
r-
,..
r• f :hr 1
c. r • r
1.0 . ;,,, ,• ,
::.. {
~" :• ", -, -, � :~••'_ zY ^ {' �`?, „i•`•t•,- '::'•.'a_: : 1.
:rti r
` t:
3� .
"r
C ' • -z, � k 'rti -`� '•' s :. . t ,`:: •
. . - _ i.. i J::' , L S' S
r i' { : r ,
y} y . r s
W I r .5 t'. �.�, : tom L- � ,? f_ i ' •.�., 4 -
\:, A
, 11 ` } :yam, ` - 1.; :•,
pis R. ; .
.` -' - �'
�. �: • ti O
;.,�
•. 1
�T. • . j •' :l' .'' t
:i \..
L
, s: %i:
e
_ y :
?�.
t
•ft'=
�.'
I'll 1 -.
, L
V .
.s " • ;rti' w • ' :. Y.. ,Z Sr-1-.
% ryr - .: .....:i .
r ; %
} \
7)}rh
ice: . �`s`Lf v�r'i + w Ya +'•:- . ; ;�''. �:. -.
r? �r,•r, - :.) - _: 4 a \ , . s'•ti _tir::
t : '. -;:
r L . • 1. .,
L'l :.L 2• ~ , ' Yt tii�L SA �'i: Si,• •♦ u` y .
},,
wrrc. < r't - :c ai1}• {t —%%L .:: - ,- "i�''• -:
• 9^ 1 7 t� —5 - , . %'� g,- r�lk' f.••)-v tti ..•.
rt " i - -; !_ • �^�Ti�a•rr�i .r.: :f• +i:i%. ^.
•yi; v . jI , i `h,•T _ ,. dry. • { :.a 4: S • . -. .
a '��, C i t t' 'i:> , • = ; %, -, fr ,:tip
•.4Z; •] ^'9 titif ` 1`✓..%c { r•- r��'�•. yy~�•Lr.••,' r '• ft ti T+r•'L --
JJ��•'� �y f � • ' ' + L,t -744 !! K -gar ✓s\. :4: .. y -::.
.. Y •e' ti �'.rr �+ •`.c a 'yti >.•Lf. -- r• rY � r t,Ky%r-'." "k%,]`r,� :Y i
i•:i ~ �L:yfy} • K� " ` :ty s •.L.'i i i ' N' • : ,L: •: :, t
pS '1 .� 1 - t:..;.`t'.1 =,:: ti,i>;y 7:.� �•�. ti �: -• - !:
•.� '. _ C�•.•+4�.1:ti�: ?rti••.
y= ' L t`
1 itir `'} • Ce ti! ` �.1aU -• . yc2::
{, t "S
-tt 11 . a ,f
• f t, , — � , - , , . O = V
�r�: f •h : 4
i' '�.: i •
L% .. - },- :..•tip,?..
_ y rr s, a• �1
- �}
"tti . I +. % , ' . )-,.
is , • rfs ::; ; +• A r
YyJ `r' �:? ': < },.;iy`�•YtitiY: :Sa ;'{
sf
fy ��- f I ,- 1 .; ; •..
. ? kip M -., ly :v?'Y ::
YS' ry' ►i tit. }:: k,
�� - t f,4.: '�
Z:'r f r 11'•e ^: ' _: r }, tom
iSSC' � I.
• ✓ �� S. ;, tii ,i} %
Zic y� ' i,E rr} ���
, �� I �---.-��,-:--- , - .. �-�
f 11 •' ry , _ ;t t 7•'•;•- ::;r, - .,. �Vd? 'r \
r � % � r�� sue; ,�.:z:r;�s' isi,- �a',r % - e p 3 Yit .ti. ' u `s
.. �' `� ----Z4t. -: , 'SZ yi ' ti _ y+S�Y:
� % r.� rte Y ot
i 1�h.L ; z r3} , -,;�; ,ays r? ° ;: " =';t -' f�'�:_-
r * y t- `rJ� { c f Yi' a ..: �f ,: ++ tr;:
', . :: �w 1.
4Y.'
F + y. r": t . y1 `':t � ? .tr '!;"S " �I:e.;; :: . . Z - t
b.: 411' .� .. rl% ? �I.1 1?SJ�S: \� -. . .. w.. -_.... :�+i :.'l.': \:S'
y [' f:� ` S \ (l�. ].•A - '�.+1'••l , Y; ti'•:_. • .!,• i s. �:[yi i .frfl.,
.vI , ., r` .
0.
r . I ,,rr.. ��i, � WIWI .:':3� -
ta-- r• - a..;' :�- . - •tti ph i•'. i .� - C).'{
�,- • :'s
rr.
l . ..til
a •tr•
Y.
�.Lt . ti' Z: ` I
7. t' _ P
-, '
1:
.. • :3
I . i `:3 3ti - ,` % � ;� .;•; ;. �? Y, :s• -
C' ?
. . . r.S f�ti•rt. ` .1::�, :• ? -~• ?- F: : yr ti,.j.I..ti • • 1'•l.:
c •i'aF iiifff r-
s)::
�, t•.
f
ti •'t r -�
y ' -ti .
Jar •ir tif;:
. � .Sf
; s�' f
:., { • jU �
$: ti ti t
r3.. K=
.n Y C s\ , f ti ? ,. �eS�(faf•'•y rS�' _ I r .�.; r- S� -y.:t ti ti
%Sr.••.• . _ r . ,_- . ?'• S1r_ a i?i -'Y ::� a i �`�. ' • 3`. ;`- .1�.�'] :V
-•�•t - . ,y, - �� r \•- •• -
-01 il�, i �ti L +T i �' j:• •ra .`.. ,t,:.�a::i i � 1 v,L a S -. 1.
;yam` ^4;.,ii'�uG:`'ai kr LL � } :+ Vii:, y; -. C�:�`f r
f h . r ': t :5,• z . s,� : "' S-,:c L , 7.1 4 S. \t - LA S ; ,
�.Cf! ••?%% ; �- "- -. • ,'..•'i ti's •.tip ':+•• I . 1 r � f ' , :, •r. - pit. • -; . r� -: - �,
�� '` a�i 'ti -� t s i - :N - , I �` , , , -
,,,O h ,- 4 s
r .ti: ••"�s.�'f `' /':'rti r rLti�•� {,\4:. •:Sti: t.�, r.
Y ': r , -.1r, " �
r ' k. ii J/ tea; •:-- = -.:•.r ;,v•L1
J _ 1 +Fl y ' $•• N' T
�?r , L - s;. J :.�ri �'": y ,y ,r rl ;.ef _}.- r ;C" ,-, , ". , I••
y/ r1 r im Je F' / in::ti r' 1
," / y � , a' y• ;rti - •l': '.,' :w :�` z fib' :.; z r ::: -: - ,:,.. ."
p E•�" < - �:L' S `r' IT ''sys .:.. �v74i.
I _ •i ti �.,'^��L (r .'•s . - '.< .� Vj• �r`ti•.L ��,. �:�. ( Sf'f��:�.:..
Ar, t3 y Im � j ` _ tc } �_. il'.. i - - 1,:;' r %:iti.a /�r�,
. 'e . 1 .\'• y ,. '%>'aS'' 71j4: • ,.: , .:a:: �:: :•. ; - a : •.•, - ' t. r • .±
.•Y.. ? 7
;i .:
,�,y `
:�
.L.. -'4 1 ,�.:
S S r'
Y7 . I '}`�
>� - aye Jt . vr�./_�y� elL 11111��� ry� • •'V'�!v• , SS• / / +� J•{~[ - if:�`i! f • ' .s nib ���C;]
� S y l/, . t, T ' :.' -n 3' : 1,• �f[= %7 /r- '�'ti•l n,.ti..i�•:a .•'!.
.P i n -•Z 1 r2•:4 -�}rr .' ' • ' J:: i r. - :• �. ?'.: lar/ �` <.n,x:t� •�:: .t its �" ''t -: � _S -': - N ; ,�. ='
arc V'{f� fi ' • t� 7 ti• ::.• r 1 •y :-`• ?ris=J :t.a..5
:"-;. :, ' _ ; te r - •.a:: - -, r :
y r ` 5 , r h f� :f� ` C. .g' F : E: .ba { >•• tirt?f�
2 ,, r 7j ,}'ya ru,! 'v'- 7f,, • �j�:y fL . t .. _� ,: `�' '.S�..a•. i i . I r •',�' :r.1tl . r ti7� {�7 I .��w }. � ( %.gi ;i i'� ••��rC .,.
♦ t �,��� 7 �. •: a.a A: S:r
'\ rK,`i \ 'Yr { : jr = y':' {. i 'f••' <_ ^- 1r�'._ :_- �::- :sy"�i•- 'mot -:� - ��{ ag
r 1 \ Y +_ rZ3' !? i + . , ;�a+r : y ��t;vi� : i•`_'^ !! +;
MnJ C = �rN
.-I _ ;ti: •G f +y '+ • Yr,F,: f n"y5
+} :i .: sue" �;. • y ` 3S �
,-• ti
Cr ~ , • fi r '. :.• 4•' -!' ` 'a {t'`V'`=''= "`P "LZ • ± • r y :- _, ,?..( -� 1 'J \ n th f-y --':` rti - �f.'niL� IM
K S
•' . a hr -.��� S - ;,�•, ✓. �, ,ti's'
ry •.tie •may
a'
- , -
_• rr `C9 ti
1 y r y s i
:Q+ r. - 1 y
j, r t r rr ,� r
'), �&.[ '-.,, r.,..-... "y"' Q
M � � . k.
L i , , � •• �
fi W .ate J� r : r 5,\•: , , ,r ?.�
2?y��} . ..: 7
r. ,?�'.••. rr • �. iS+' ski +�'ri ti r
�.,, :r.
7Cf` _ r .� f • r : }( :Y.f 1 r^ rT r ;la ro.. ) , r +_•eFti
f r' -.
7a ( V I 1 •_-•,:•.•'�,rY.= is ti-' - Y /- ,�T'`�,T!••, ,..� -•i ... •�
r
`,• �h <.� . Z •=;aS �t Iran •iiY i ?ZiCt %.r}4
,. L 4; },. `tit =} ' 1 3� Y • � , gL�' a:• -
e d- a c } . I C Y . :� r. ''� r J,1 2 : W.
if SS ?C ,r♦ , r : %
}1y '``t rl.• • - rl + ••��•C'y.;
i'z;' `• 1 ,,, r a - .h am ;1 PP
_r ea • s a w C!r:fC� ^ s f • s x: i-'r
' {
...
"I
F ✓
r c ���
r , s.,•sY7i L -
. y ':
r 4-:
�s
a -
? Ls���:
�. ; tom ,�
� , r* � -"
�. r
�. fs
i-y a %�%,%
..I - .t • -•tit
? Fes` - �;t> • �r
a 'd A , , - . f.