HomeMy WebLinkAboutWater and Wastewater Rate Survey Results June 1998IV
Howard R. Green
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
June 29, 1998
City of Oak Park Heights
Mayor Schaaf
City Hall
P. O. Box 2007
Oak Park Heights, MN 55082 -2007
Dear Mayor Schaaf:
IiJ
JUL L lgy J' M
111
.311.11,0 Y,1�IS®ILS
Formerly MSA
Consulting Engineers
Enclosed are the results of the Water and Wastewater Rate Survey conducted by Howard R.
Green Company. The information you gathered and sent to us regarding your water and
wastewater rates has been received and analyzed.
Howard R. Green appreciates the time investment your city made by gathering the information
needed in the survey, and we would like to thank you for your efforts. We believe that the
enclosed data will be a useful tool when you make your next evaluation of water and
wastewater user rates. Due to the high level of participation, your city and other communities
now have an up-to -date information source.
The following report tabulates data on current population, date of the last rate increase for water
and wastewater, and minimum billing amounts. It also provides monthly user rates based on
three water use, or wastewater discharge, levels of 5,000 gallons, 10,000 gallons, and 50,000
gallons per month per meter.
The results of the survey data are intended to offer information that can be utilized by city
officials and city policy makers. The information also allows for comparisons of water and
wastewater rates between communities of similar size.
Again, thank you for your participation. If Howard R. Green Company can offer you any other
information or be of further service to your city, please contact me at 1- 888 - 368 -4389.
Sincerely,
HOWARD R. GREEN COMPANY
CL
Chris L. Catlin, P.E.
CLC:tw
Enclosure
1326 Energy Park Drive • St. Paul, MN 55108 • 612/644 -4389 fax 612/644 -9446 toll free 888/368 -4389
INSURANCE SERVICES OFFICE, INC.
111 NORTH CANAL STREET SUITE 950 CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60606 -7270 (312)930 -0070 (800)444 -4554 FAX: (312)930 0n':
June 19, 1998
Mr. Thomas M. Melena
City Administrator
City of Oak Park Heights
14168 N. 57th St.
Box 2007
Oak Park Heights, MN 55082
Dear Mr. Melena:
D L�C�[�DbG
JUL 1996
Enclosed is the information you requested on June 15, 1998
concerning the City of Oak Park Heights. If you have a need
for clarification or for more information please contact us
at the address above or phone (800)930 -1677 ext. 6232 or
6208 or fax (312) 930 -0017.
Very truly yours,
Robert Shoemaker
Community Classification Services Analyst
CLASSIFICATION DETAILS
Municipality Oak Park Heights___ State MN.__ PopuLation 259
Date Surveyed_September 1 988 Total Credit 48.37 Class 6
SUMMARY OF CREDIT
�' Maximum
Assigned Credit
Receiving and Handling Fire Alarms 8.20 % 10.00%
Fire Department 17.64 50.00
Water Supply 30.96 40.00
*Divergence —8.43
487 100. b0%
The Public Protection Class is based on the total percentage
credit as follows:
Class %
1
90.00
or
more
2
80.00
to
89.99
3
70.00
to
79.99
4
60.00
to
69.99
5
50.00
to
59.99
6
40.00
to
49.99
7
30.00
to
39.99
8
20.00
to
29.99
9
10.00
to
19.99
10
0
to
9.99
*Divergence is a reduction in credit to reflect a difference in the
relative credits for Fire Department and Water Supply.
The above classification has been developed for fire insurance rating
purposes only.
n r, c
tJ a5 H99
O N 3 z P�7 r
R 5 c A
H• f0 (D
(D n Ham
N h H-
M
(D N x z
G (D M 0 b7
or
H
0 a O a m
fD na
O II ti> H
£ O a a
aznra
M O r
O N � M
n ace no
N rt [h
r G t M�
n r CA Hl'1
r• H a
a
r
R
n
Oa
m
n
G
N
N
r•
M
n
G
n
0
O
0
M
CL
r
H
G
0
7
0
O
H
rn
(* F
7• r
n r
n
W
rt
m
7
r
N
F-
7
DD
n
n
O
CL
rt
n
O
a
w
n
r •
O
n
7
tD
n
r
z
n
r.
o.
L7
F '�1
J M
n r
n
N ^-7
o E
x»
;n
n
m
r
c
O
O
ti C z
£ H C
z z z
M • n
v, ra
M H
ox
LT1 H
C n
H b
r c
mro
M 0
E z
�e
z
r�l O
d H
r H
n z
nt
r -: 7
H
G)
H
O O
z •'7
oa
a°
z y
r -. x
v: c
H 3
c
H O
Z
H
lw lw
n I�
M M
m G
r. r.
r• r•
r• H•
R R
H• w
r r
N N
— H —
Oy
OH
H K
�ro
H�
H
t�
y
H
O
H
H
O
n G r z
rt R
� a
^ l 0 — I0 l0 l0 l0
..._y' CJI
O — �O
co
it C, c l _
I I� I� c y rn
n n y
I O ' G II [9
rn i i zt
I I I I c c G t O o 0
k
rl'
f �
I�
I
I
!x
I
Oo
00
xO
K
zn
H�
�9 C
E tn
qx
Hm
> m
c C
s ° n
>cn
H
2
n
�
a
C
O
G
n
ro
c
r
n
n
r•
2+
c
�•
O
m
O
R
z
CD
O
X
X
7
o•
F
H
c
n
— H —
Oy
OH
H K
�ro
H�
H
t�
y
H
O
H
H
O
n G r z
rt R
� a
^ l 0 — I0 l0 l0 l0
..._y' CJI
O — �O
co
it C, c l _
I I� I� c y rn
n n y
I O ' G II [9
rn i i zt
I I I I c c G t O o 0
k
rl'
f �
I�
I
I
!x
I
Oo
00
xO
K
zn
H�
�9 C
E tn
qx
Hm
> m
c C
s ° n
>cn
H
2
n
II
I
I
Water and Wastewater
Rate Survey Results
June 1998
Dward R, Green Company
VSULTING ENGINEERS
WATER AND WASTEWATER RATE SURVEY RESULTS
Results of the water and wastewater rate survey distributed by Howard R. Green
Company have been tabulated. Surveys were sent to 279 communities in Minnesota
with populations ranging from 155 to 396,000. Responding to the rate survey required a
fair amount of effort on the part of the communities and we feel fortunate that
approximately 50% of the surveys were returned.
A wide variety of billing methods was encountered in the returned surveys. As an
example, billing cycles included monthly, bimonthly, and quarterly cycles. The rates for
communities also varied by the flow units used in calculating the bills for water and
wastewater. Typical volume units were cubic feet and gallons. For this report the data
was normalized into monthly rates based on gallons in order to allow comparison of all
communities.
It should also be noted that the communities in this report provide various levels of
' treatment and utilize a variety of treatment methods. This variability can result in
different treatment qualities and costs, which can affect user rates.
Data
The following charts of the data collected for water and wastewater user rates
summarize the information gathered in the survey. Rates for monthly usage are shown
and explanations for rate differences are suggested. Factors affecting billing rates are
also proposed.
The raw data is included on subsequent sheets. It is organized first by size of
community, and shows the information for communities based on population ranges of
0- 2,500, 2,500- 10,000, and greater than 10,000. A second set of data is organized
alphabetically by community name. Information regarding community population,
minimum billing amounts, monthly charges, and the date of the last rate increase can be
found on these pages.
Water Rate Results
The chart on the following page represents median water rates by usage in three
quantities: 5,000, 10,000, and 50,000 gallons per month per user. The data is
presented in three population ranges. All rates are based on residential monthly usage.
1 O: \GEN \1233 \Water Rate Study \400.2208.jan.doc Page 1
O
0
9
O
N
d
N
L
2 �
c
R
d
.70
t
C
p O
H
L
O O
LO a
m
�a
O L
v m
m
0
co
O
O
0
o _
A
O o Ln
O N
C)
O
N
uoi;eindod
OL
Q
01.
N
a N
N
C N
N
C N
m N
o f
o f
o f
O L
O L
O L
O C
O C
O C
60
60
0 0
u) E
E
L6
❑
®
0
O
0
9
O
N
d
N
L
2 �
c
R
d
.70
t
C
p O
H
L
O O
LO a
m
�a
O L
v m
m
0
co
O
O
0
o _
A
O o Ln
O N
C)
O
N
uoi;eindod
II
' The survey results show little variation in water rates between the three population
groups. However, communities with populations greater than 10,000 have, in general,
charged lower rates than the smaller communities. This trend suggests that larger
i communities are benefiting from economies of scale. Factors that can affect community
water rates include:
I • Quality of the source water,
• Availability of the water supply, and
' • Distribution system requirements
The above factors can be very difficult to quantify, as well as control, and can have a
large impact on the rates that communities charge. Communities should look at the
various factors that influence their own water rates when evaluating the survey results.
The water rate data can also be evaluated based on the amount of water usage per
customer. Customers using 5,000 gallons per month or less had an average water bill of
$10.66, customers using 10,000 gallons per month or less had an average water bill of
' $18.26, and customers using up to 50,000 gallons per month had an average water bill
of $78.46. Water usage between these volumes can be interpolated with reasonable
accuracy.
Many communities have a base rate for water usage each month. This base rate is
necessary to cover infrastructure costs that are independent of the amount of water
used each billing period. Minimum billing rates for water ranged from $0.00 to $34.50
per month.
I Wastewater Rate Results
Chart No. 2 on the following page represents median wastewater rates by volume
generated in three quantities: 5,000, 10,000, and 50,000 gallons per user per month.
Data is presented in three population ranges. All rates are based on residential monthly
' usage.
As was the case for water rates, the results show little variation in wastewater rates
between the three population groups. Again, communities with populations greater thar
10,000 are generally charging less for wastewater service than smaller communities,
suggesting that larger communities benefit from economies of scale. Factors that affect
community wastewater rates include:
' • Influent quality and necessary pretreatment requirements,
• Effluent quality and discharge permit requirements,
• Availability of disposal options, and
' • Collection system characteristics such as lift stations and age of the infrastructure
I
' 0:1GEN \1233\Water Rate Study\400- 2208.jan.doc Page 3
O
N
O
O
U)
4)
4)
t6
3
m
N
t6
C
t6
'a
4)
L
O
W L
C
O
E
A
0
O N
L
m
A
3
N
N
•t
O
N
0
I
A
o
O N
O
O
tfJ
N
uoi;eindod
CL
N
N
C m
N
C N
N N
o E
o f
c E
rnn
rna
0
0,a
O L
O L
O L
0
O
O
0
Ln E
E
vi E
❑
�
B
O
N
O
O
U)
4)
4)
t6
3
m
N
t6
C
t6
'a
4)
L
O
W L
C
O
E
A
0
O N
L
m
A
3
N
N
•t
O
N
0
I
A
o
O N
O
O
tfJ
N
uoi;eindod
The above factors can vary widely between different communities and can have a
significant impact on the user rates necessar/ to handle the debt retirement and annual
operation and maintenance costs. Communities should weigh these factors when
comparing user rates in their community to those charged by other communities.
The data for wastewater rates can also be compared based on the amount of
wastewater generated by system users. Households producing 5,000 gallons or less of
wastewater per month had an average wastewater bill of $15.18, households producing
10,000 gallons or less of wastewater per month had an average wastewater bill of
$24.56, and households producing up to 50,000 gallons of wastewater per month had
an average wastewater bill of $99.06.
Similar to water usage, many communities have a base rate for wastewater disposal.
Many costs incurred by communities are for the connection of houses to the system,
and are independent of the flow produced by the user. The minimum billing rates for
wastewater ranged from $0.00 to $38.00 per month.
Summary
' We would like to sincerely thank all of the communities and individuals who participated
in the rate survey. This report should prove to be a valuable tool for superintendents,
utility personnel, city managers, and elected officials to use for comparative purposes.
Please note: If you believe your community's rate data has been presented in error, do
not hesitate to notify us. Mail any corrected or updated information to Howard R. Green
Company, 1326 Energy Park Drive, Saint Paul, MN 55108, Attn: Chris Catlin, or call
612- 644 -4389. We will be glad to publish any corrected information in our monthly
newsletter, The Green Update.
' OAGEN\1233 \Water Rate StudyWO- 2208.jan.doc Page 5
I
1
1
1
I
1
I
I
I
I
APPENDICES
' 0: \GEN\1233 \Water Rate Study400- 2208.jan.doc
APPENDIX A
' Water Rate Survey Data - Alphabetical by City
i�
I
u
I
F7
L
I
' 0: \GEN \1233 \Water Rate Study \400- 2208.jan.doc
O N
Q
N
O O
(n
Q
M,—
(O
N:m
O:(O
0'Q
O O O M O 00
�
W
O'MiO
o:O:(
M
M.(D.(D
O
O:O'O:(O
M (O
O O N (O
0
O U
CO
� w
vi
�
w
11 W
•�
D
D
O
:.� O N
I�'(D'Q
�+
�
N N
O
U7
�.�'�
Q
.-
N.(DV
Q
Q�.N'.M
(p
N•.N •M ir`'r
M O
cO
X10 : u'i:0 (fl
I�
O O
n
�
O
R� r.. o7
M
(!l:
Hi - (A YA fA Yi!(H _ fA fA
Vf'fA fA
69
fA�
to
EA
(H
'WtA
'ice
N,(R'r
�fA
-fA
�fA'i� fA
fA
r.(A
(H69 69
kA'.
Vi:'N ifH.r -:fA
tl9'.-
E9
tH
f9 :f9lA
tR.
fA
'M
tA'
fA'
6
O N
Q
N
O O
(n
Q
o M Q ((1
O
N 1 M O
O O O M O 00
0 0 O O O
0
0
O
M (O
O O N (O
0
0
CO
•�
D
D
O
:.� O N
N r N
� �,
Q
fA (H
(A
fH
fA fA
fA
f9
UA fAl (A
(!l:
Hi - (A YA fA Yi!(H _ fA fA
f9
i fA
(AW tO
fA tR
fA fA
fA
fH'Vl
Vi Yi (A fA
fH
to tA.
_T
U
T
m
(d
U
a)
m
L
_Q
Q
(4
(6
T
N
7
U)
N
(4
N
�.O I�.(D M O O (O
r' m aD - O Oi0 Q OOJ (V u'1 O 1��<h��0 O M N(o (fi C'1 ON'(nOc� VID7Ul (D O1 OO O
I� (O O O
N O co I� O N O O O O 01 ((1 Q o7: �O O O:N MN.O((] r.M (D �i� Q'Q (fl (D O LL'1 (O O O'M 'O.
� (D m O Q tD O N Q w (D v (O ' N. O h N W (D O m r O) OW N .- O YI w O O O N OJ O
EA Hi fA � fA (A N 'tA (A fA fA fA � fA (A M hA.� Nf (fl N fH M tA(A Vi' fA (A N
fA (A fA fA fA MfA ' fA' bi fA to fA fA- fA (A kA (A tAfA' fA fA M (A' fR
p, M O O D 07 O O V'1 Q O c'i O O�O - i•J f� fO 1� Q C1 0 0 0 M O C) M. O O O O O O
O
(D O (D O W O) O I� O N N O (O (p Q N (D ' O (n 0 M. O O Q1 O O O O O
Q Oo M N M co N O M Q m M O N (D (D (D Q (D M N (O (O Q Q m N (D O N Q M (D N M M N O
m. Vi H3 69 kA fA � 69 69 (A � (A M fA fA (A EH 69 V3 FA (9 EA 69 N £A fR (R fA 69 (A EA 69 kA (A fA M 69 69 VT 69 EA (A to to fA (A fA fH N
69 fA fA H3 (H
�
G
C_
d
`m
(O N co V (D (D (O M O M r r o M tD u7 iD N D7 n O r n Q r (D aD
N Q1 W m Ol m T 61 O1 O) m - — - m - - m - — — - — m — — m — m — — — — O m � T OJ 01 DJ
N — — — — — — — — N e- \ N — — — — \ e- — — — ` — r — — — — — --
d iD r — — — — r- '- — N I— N n Cl N (f1 O r c'l r I—
G
6f
M E
H
w
O
d
A
O
O O Q O Q M Q1 O O O
O( 0 0 W W= 0 0 m
O (D m O O '- O O N M O O O M O Q O M M LL O N N (D 0 N Q O I�
O W N r V M N C6 Ui M M N C5 O(o M M ifl ( i O co M r M 0 N Q N` N co co 6 N (h r
(I'7
d
E N O N
L 'O 0
C C C C O C QI r0 J L O C S W 0 u- m C v7
U C C m > C N a U a D O �- = r j C L N O C m T O O O] 3 O.
0 X C O fl_ Y T U N N E C t U O O t C � C > @ N N O� O t9 0 3 7 01 O� VI N U .� O O TJ E N
O C C fl, m (6 w N w N N O] N O D] J T m m L r L O O N N (O Y Y T> X O1 N N . - OJ N _
Q Q Q Q Q Q m= m 0] m m co co m m m m m U U U U U U U U❑0 ❑ W W W W W W LL. LL. LL LL. C7 C7 U' S = 2 S
m m m m m m m m m m
O m 0 N O W O I O w M r 0 O N r O O M O M O O N O M O O M M N N N O C N O O O
O N N C O O) O (D N M O N O (D N M O r O M r 0 M M O O f` M O N O N N w O N OJ N N O O C r
M N C N O O)
Vi fA fA fA fo r to Vi to fo to to fA FA to to fA fo W fA Vi to fo fA to FA fo fA fo fA fA to to fA fA to r V3 to to fA r
69 (o V3 fo fo fA
_T
U
T
Go
(D
U
Q
(6
L
_Q
Q
i
M
T
N
7
U)
N
(6
N
N
i
m
O M O M O N O O W <p O f` O O M M N N O O C M O O O
r [O M M N C n (p r M (A M O N N M .- O N O M (O O M OJ C) co O r C (D M O O M D) M .-- r O O N
fo N – r r r r N N N r N – N V N r – M r N to N r to M N N N fA r N
to FA Vl to to E V 0 to to to to to to to to to F to 6% to to FA FA fA V� to fA FA Vi to to Vi fA to to fo tR to fH to
_ — r ___ _.. _._ _ _ __ ) __ t
M N M O - N - O - N 0 (6 O N'O (D m N _ - O N N N O N r o r - - )D O M O (p' N N N CO W 0 N to M O O O
N N to tD r fp N N N Q) M N (D (D N h � O N r O N N
MN D7 - r M O O N a0 tD (O W'M M (O CD r -Q)N CN.r r Om C 0 O'N 1� C I� Cr N.O �M 01 CO C.O'O C
M'fo fA to r '(0'69 fA IfA fR' FA •to fo fA'69 N'. tF) r.fo'FA � fo'tA to to r fA Yi'r
fA fA FA - to to to fA to '.fA to to �fo fA to fo 69 '..fA FA 'fA V3 fA
"M YLO
O
0-
ON
O
"O
I
- O
O�
N'
O N r-
a
C!O 'M!O
0 0
O
o o 7 6 U
N
O
n n
U) r
0
(D�
o��
o
O
tYJl O
I� O
H O
0
0 0
W (D
M�
0 (D
N
O
M
r - I"N
01
0)
m
O
O (D '
(D (O
O
N N'O N'I"O
r
N
N N
N
M
–
--
–
r o
MO
C N
N M N
O
C N
O N (D
O'tA
N C
N
M
m M M
N
(p M O
-N
O
N
r N
N
O
NIN
M
r r
o
O
r
O
N C
fA'tA
FA Vt
to to to
Vf
to '.EA
rA- ,tA -to
E9
to'tA
FAM Vt'fA'tA
N.tA to
to
EA to'fo
fA.fo
FA'tAfo
W
Vi ifA
Io.FA
r�'to
fA',M.fA
to to
�'EA
-_.
NiO'O'O.O
0010 O O
C
- O
O�O O
N'
010
l O
o 010
C!O 'M!O
1"O)'pIN;N':N
O O
n n
U) r
0
r N
r 0 O
Lo
N '(D r
h
-
C ''('1 M
1(!J
M
l7 N
0)
m
. O) D1
N
iN
r
r r
M
–
--
–
–
1�
� `
r
N 0010 N O i(D:N•M!(D CC N N'.O (p
1A:00:'O N O N.r N M rIN I(�
t` N co C •- 'C .N'N!NI(D•O) r N. '.O N'.(D '.- (V'N
O 0.0
NiO'O'O.O
0010 O O
C
- O
O�O O
N'
010
l O
o 010
C!O 'M!O
1"O)'pIN;N':N
O O
O10 CO
CD
W '(D'
0
r N
r 0 O
Lo
N '(D r
'("1
r
C ''('1 M
1(!J
M
l7 N
�'I�IN
N
iN
r
M
N
L L
(U O) N O N N U
C> N N J O Y = s Y O N 0 L O C C N
C N Ur O C C C U W C O O` (0 U LL LL O N UI J (0 N l9 W O (0 Y p 0 U O O tU 0 07 U@ CL
d O). . N C Y O C Y N Ql N C O N N Ol D L C d d" 0 N T O �G C C C C QI .0 G 3 co 0
J'J �',� �.� �.�.�'� �'':� �� Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Q O'O O
m m m m m m m m
vq'�o
o1
cdi
oi�4
In - M
iv
`N oo',:oi.r
--
G) O — diL
om(om(c
LEo`
— r - nC
rr'�_
oTOo
MM�o'
0
Qiu�
uRn�r
(D
(O
m
O'er
�
m
m'.�
O.M!N
W
m N �--; Y' m N
W
O�m'01 W
N.�
.-,MIO m'm
O
N
r:N,O
O
O
r
NCO
m
r
W
O
M
M
M,N
r
r
mi0
N
V
N1
m
N: (O ;,O.W •-'�
u')
W'N
m to m
V',N
0 O Q7
M
m
r Q
V
Q
U�
M Q
m.m
N
ll�
�n
r'r
rn.Q
ran
�n�mm
o
fA' t9 to
r.o'f» �rn
o .(n
rn Q m:rn�m
11 �
�n�'�.Q Q,(n
IHM
tA!fH fA
bi'..fAb9
'
fR:f9:(H
•NT.,W
lR:tAfA fA
f9'f9
V3fA EA�fAfA'M
�
f9'fA
E9'fAtH
»
fA,EH
f9'fA
fA'�'69'fA'fA
i69 - en� f9.�'.�
»IVi
T
vi
_ C5
o1
-
r
In - M
-- -
°
�
--
0
Qiu�
uRn�r
(D
^
°'co
o
O
Ol '
�Q
V NIV,�
N:�O'O
O
O'NO'N'N
O
fA' t9 to
f9
to
Vi fA'
tA:IA
IHM
tA!fH fA
bi'..fAb9
'
fR:f9:(H
•NT.,W
lR:tAfA fA
f9'f9
V3fA EA�fAfA'M
tAtA'fA
E9'fAtH
f9 ip tA.b9
'O O O O M O O m M O m O C N O O m O 0 0 V V O .r- W a m 0 0 0 M r o N O O r N M Q N O W
0 0 r N V
fA V� fA fA fA fA to FA to Vi fA fA to fq fA tR fA fA f9 fA fA fA fA W to fA f9 fH fA V-1 N � N fH fA IA FA fA fA to fA fA Vf fA to
to fA fA fA fA
3
C
L
d
N
61 01 OJ m \ m m 6] - - - W m - - T - - - - - m - - m 4) m m - - W T - O
m
r
A
L
O O O V O O O m O m O 0 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 M Q m N m O O N 0 0 0 - o O W O N 0 Q O 0 0 0 0
M O O- O Q O r r 0 m m O 0 0 r� N (D 0 Q O n V O O M Om ' m O m O M UJ O N m Q M r �{ m Q 0 0
O O r W m Q M - N - - M Q) tfJ if] m N co Co Lo W m M M Ol N VJ m N
M
N @
Z ( D m N Vl C Y on LL N O @ J
m >i O >. m Y d @ O O) C CL
V m E 3 m L a Y `m a a s s m ° m m °' c U m 0 a 3 3 -° = E .o .c ( o w m CL N C m E
1 3 >` @ m (? (? 0 0 0 0 0 7@@ m L L L m 0 O. d d- m .- @ L 3
m = = m r m m = = = m = m = = m
o1
T
vi
CO
w,
u
qS
U
Ul
L
0
O_
L
ge; C1
N�O
O'r
N
t0
O
M O
--
V
O
O N NO: N N NI^
O .M
- - -
O
-
- -
- --
rO
WE
r
O'u�
m mOiN V'O NmQ'N
(d
•���
V
W
�
m
r
m
W
V
rn'
r
m
Q
m
0
N '.W
O
N
'm
W O
W
O
m W m l� m r 0 O '.m
O '.m
0
M
O 'gym Q 'M
r h
O
W r
fA
to
�
fA
fA
ER
to
to
fA
fH
EA
ER'
�
fA fA
fA
f9
fA
to fH . to . � N M i (H'
�
N
fR
Vi �
E9 to
@
�� fit
f9
fA
tH
f9
fA
M
EA
fA tA' fA' fA fR'
fA i f»
fn
fR
fA fA to
fA
fH
T
O
7
N
co
c0
Ra
till
M:.
0
C
>
O,
'O O O O M O O m M O m O C N O O m O 0 0 V V O .r- W a m 0 0 0 M r o N O O r N M Q N O W
0 0 r N V
fA V� fA fA fA fA to FA to Vi fA fA to fq fA tR fA fA f9 fA fA fA fA W to fA f9 fH fA V-1 N � N fH fA IA FA fA fA to fA fA Vf fA to
to fA fA fA fA
3
C
L
d
N
61 01 OJ m \ m m 6] - - - W m - - T - - - - - m - - m 4) m m - - W T - O
m
r
A
L
O O O V O O O m O m O 0 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 M Q m N m O O N 0 0 0 - o O W O N 0 Q O 0 0 0 0
M O O- O Q O r r 0 m m O 0 0 r� N (D 0 Q O n V O O M Om ' m O m O M UJ O N m Q M r �{ m Q 0 0
O O r W m Q M - N - - M Q) tfJ if] m N co Co Lo W m M M Ol N VJ m N
M
N @
Z ( D m N Vl C Y on LL N O @ J
m >i O >. m Y d @ O O) C CL
V m E 3 m L a Y `m a a s s m ° m m °' c U m 0 a 3 3 -° = E .o .c ( o w m CL N C m E
1 3 >` @ m (? (? 0 0 0 0 0 7@@ m L L L m 0 O. d d- m .- @ L 3
m = = m r m m = = = m = m = = m
APPENDIX B
Water Rate Survey Data - By Population
I
7
I
I
I
I
Li
1 OAGEM1233Mater Rate StudyWOO- 2208.jan.doc
d
r.+
/fl
C
O
7
Q
O
IL
>,
m
i
N
0
T
N
7
N
(6
UJ
E
7
E
'E
m
m
m
N
A
V
C
R
a+
N
0
O
d
O
a
d
2
d
y
d
E
Z
U
0
0
0
CD
O
O
M
0
0
0
I
O
O
t
r
O
I
0
0
0
0
(n
f
In
"
I
M
(n
O
M
0
0
(n
V(
r
r
m
m
O
�[]
O
m
O
I
O
N
O
O
w
M
O
(D
(D
00
U-1
O
m
(D
O
M
O
N
(n
W
O
O
N
CO
O
O
M
W
M
M
I�
(D
r
m
M
M
O
n
m
m
O
O
M
N
M
(O
N
O
(V
M
M
N
I
M
N
O
N
I
M
(D
M
N
m
co
O
r
In
69
(n
t
r
t
M
O
r
V
N
n
u
m
r
(n
r
O
N
m
N
M
r
to
M
(D
O
m
M
(n
M
(n
(D
V
I
((l
O
O
to
to
N
to
69
69
69
r
69
69
EA
69
to
VA
r
r
to
W)
r
69
r
69
r
fA
69
r
to
69
69
Fo
69
to
69
fR
64
64
r
64
69
64
64
69
69
69
to
to
69
O
O
O
(O
O
O
M
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
O
M
O
O
m
t`
in
r
N
m
M
O
(n
O
(O
O
f-
N
(D
O
O
M
m
O
m
(D
CO
r
0
0
(n
O
M
(D
1-
O
M
O
N
(n
CO
O
O
N
M
W
N
r
O
N
(h
r
(D
m
(+)
N
0
CO
r
M
V
M
0
(O
M
V
m
V
O
N
N
m
M
m
N
O
m
(D
N
M
M
O
(D
N
M
N
r
Ui
to
r
r
M
r
r
N
N
M
r
r
N
N
M
r"
r
to
M
N
r
FA
r
N
r
r"
N
69
V9
FA
N)
to
fo
69
F
69
fA
69
69
69
to
6
6
6
to
69
69
FA
FA
to
to
to
69
69
6
to
to
6
to
fH
to
to
69
O
(O
O
(D
0
0
(n
0
0
0
O
r
O
N
O
O
0
u7
(O
N
u'1
O
N
M
O
(n
M
O
m
(n
CO
O
r
M
N
O
O
(O
t`
O
(n
(n
(D
O
m
m
(n
r
W
O
N
N
O
r
m
N
I
M
M
(n
(D
(D
r
M
O
N
r
O
0
r
M
m
(n
w
V
(n
O
m
M
m
(O
(D
m
(D
(n
r
r
to
69
N
r
r
FA
r
M
r
69
fo
FA
to
r
N
r
r
Vi
r
I
I
I
r
69
69
r
r
69
to
69
r
64
FA
to
to
to
r
Ef!
69
FA
69
69
to
fo
FA
69
69
to
to
to
69
69
to
69
to
69
69
to
O
O
O
(D
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
M
In
O
r
O
O
O
O
O
t`
O1
O
M
M
O
O
M
O
O
in
O
N
m
O
M
0
(D
0
0
(D
O
I
r
0 �
O
O
O
O
M
m
0
(D
O
m
0
(n
(O
r
O
O
M
M
0
u]
N
O
O
N
O
M
m
M
w
O
M
O
(D
(D
(O
V
N
M
M
(n
O
M
O
N
M
O
-4
O
N
E
N
N
V
M
N
V
m
M
(n
M
N
N
O
r
to
69
64
69
69
64
M
64
r
69
vi
6%
to
N
69
r
to
to
to
to
to
to
(A
to
to
69
69
to
(f-1
N
6)
64
69
64
69
69
64
fA
EfT
69
69
to
to
F9
m
rn
rn
rn
rn
rn
m
m
rn
rn
m
rn
rn
c
rn
rn
rn�
rn
rn
m
rn
rn
rn
m
rn
w
m
m
m
rn
m
rn
rn
rn
rn
N
�fJ
O
r
O
O
O
O
O
O
m
O
O
M
O
O
r
0
0
0
(O
O
O
r
m
0
0
0
M
0
(D
N
(D
O
to
I�
O
r
M
O
M
O
O
O
r
O
O
N
m
CO
O
M
M
m
M
(n
I�
0
0
CO
N
N
O
m
0
0
0
W
(O
r
r
0
r
N
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
(O
lO
u7
(D
f�
r
(\
W
N
W
m
M
m
O
r
(n
(n
(O
I�
t`
W
Ln
W
m
O
O
r
r
N
N
CO
M
V
(n
r
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
s
U
t0
T
�
�
C
Y
N
T
>
Y
O
`
m
o
E
J
m
U
E
C
O
U
>
m
C
m
a)
C
0
D
Y
o
Y
Y
3
E
1/1
T
E
N
O
C
O>
C
L
.1
m
m
'�
O
C
N
U
U
.x
U
a)
o
Ql
Y
Q
Z
2
W
m
CC
S
F
U
U
m
Y
2
x
U
2
0
U
d7
W
Q
(n
u-
to
W
J
J
J
(D
N
O
co
N
r
r
QI
V
t0
r
O
(D
m m m = m = = = = m
d O (O W p
O W W (0
d N M M M
`w
a
O •- N p
m
m
d
a
d O p N 0
O A
Lci
❑ � M M
m
N
O
C O
O O
O
N 00 O
N O
N ON O
CL O N A
O M O p w — O N �.W MGM O O O O OHO T O M W.M O N M (D (O O O O M W O.O O Oir r D) M p
m
W (D W'�W N N' V M'N. W 7 .W 01
m M r W W N p r N 'N N W
m
N N W (O .NON r ( ��W r N,(p N,N N N (D m V N.p W mm N N•p r N'�O W M (D W W
(O (On (O (O It M NO.M
M M.� M M M M M M M M M t9�WVYV3'.M MGM H1 'M M M M M'M M M M'i biW'V169 iMM fA M.� M M� M M
cn
O'
O
O
� '
O'
Yn-
C i
la
O tt
O'.O fO.p m N N W N (D.O - N ..M Oir.r r 01.0 W N N W r m'.M r p
col 0)
OIW M'A iN .O�p MO m N r M.N,W O O r Qj
M M M M M M.M:MM MM i. MM M M.'M'M '.M' M MIT -M b9.b9 M M'M MIM M k9 V3. Ni.M M M M'M W
C
O%
O
o
0
m
O'
C
CL
0
O
a
m'
T
9
0
e
T
a)
O
m W r m NN N O p W't0 O NN OO O mN W N MiW N r M
. .'' ..
'MIM
M M •- M- M M -.M M -,M M -M.M M I� M M M M M M M M M M M M M.MI� M N M M
(n
,Q
m
0
m
m
c
Q
o c] o oo 0 o N - N - rn M "oi - o o r o 0 0 oMorno o - o V (O N M - o o - v o W v o - o �n r r o o N p p
E
C
d
A
r p N r r r r W W W M (O r r N co co N N_ -. �I� W _V i0 (0 -_..r r (0 - W r W O O W W 0) r W r d
d
m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m
— — r r — .- O r
zz- z d
�
a
V
N
m
O
d
A
O O N (0 N O r N 0 0 0 0 N N O O O m O 0 0 0 m 0 ? 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (D O O N O O O O O
N N co M M p N N N N N (O r r r W co m 0 M N (0 r W W o N CO M 7 (O r o (D O O O co W
d
- - — — — — — — •'- — — — — — — — — — — — — — N N N N N N N N M M M p V p p N N (p (O O r m
C
O
7
CL
0
a
d
m d m
E
Z d
O
'
O 07 = d C O L
5 U N L
Y y= Y C d O d d Y d
E
aL
d L L 0 N 0 L L> U
d 0 m O O m J d O d L m '3 O m m C 3 0 O m 0_ J
IL Z��2LL Z w co U (n(n() Kaa �OZZ30 so�LLU Q U)ZW mm d 2 co
d O (O W p
O W W (0
d N M M M
`w
a
O •- N p
m
m
d
a
d O p N 0
O A
Lci
❑ � M M
m
N
O
C O
O O
O
N 00 O
N O
N ON O
CL O N A
n OOi0W000��a00 WOOWOO �.Q m nNOTNOOOTOO m'Qip WNNO(7 W'OiN OO OIM N ". tO M1.tOW NrPO
W O
C
O
7
O
O
EL
T
m
f0
t0
T
N
2
J
d
f0
d
nOOm NOru 1nONOO m�0Ot0 OOPPWONO NOOOOO O fOrOrwV]O [7 (D O.W O[OOrN!- NPOnOWNmP['I
NN m r N O m � 0 a O r O O m r m0 O P m r P O m N N (O P O b tD m'O W N N O r N m'a OJ O O r WN P m r � m W W P a't'1
w w w w w wwww w..w w w www ww w w w.w w w w w w w w.w w wwww w.w www,w w w w' ww w w w w w w w w w..w
Q.�
O I� n O Q P N rn OI a CI Q n P O a a�
w Vf w w w w w w
(O Ol O O O O G w m O W O O a n O
r N P
N Q O l P m m m o m N r Om (J rN r a m r W r N a CJ O N.N mIN fO I`Y
P 10 O O a0 a0 W fD gym..- W � O^ CI Oe tD P fD � O a r0 ^ N (O'.W t9' 4J
w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w N w w N w w w w w wwww www w w w w www w.w www w.w wwww w
w w w
mw r r r r d r N a r r r r r C'1 W Q m �- tD n !D r m P O m r Yt :O fO r r m r r a W t0. W W O m n W r r n Q M1 M1 m
of aaaa aQQa mm a a `l rnrn aaaa arnarnaamaa am aaa as mam of a W wolTQ arnof aaaof w
r to v— z z Q z 7z r r N
f' W N N � � (O � � t0 F p m r � � �
WNOPOOOWO—W00 ON W'tDOOmQt00 000000QONtO ONOPO - Q Oma00WfM1 Om OQ O00 - Ot-0
p m W O cO O t7 (O (O P O O O O Q W O O N
O O O M m t0 m'O m O O N O m O t0 O N M m Q N C l C 7 fp l0 O N N'.O t7 W.O O N P O r 0 V 0 0 0 W O
m m m t0 tp r r r r W O O O N N N N tO n r r m m a O O �- N O O r W CD fD tp a � � m (7 � P P M1 o tll Q O
N N N N N N N N N N N t'1 (7 t7 t7 t7 t'> t'1 t7 t'1 t'1 t7 t7 CI (7 C'I t7 t'1 t'1 t'1 Q P Q Q P Q m N m m v1 m m m t0 (O t0 tD n n W W W W W a Ol OI O
� N
C p N CL
pl O H y N` O O U d d LL y O
m d C a } N C N O 7 d y= 7 m IL C O m V Y Y m A
E 3 0 0 l ° o E'm m m
a o o '° i c y �. o . '-° U '� c- c E U E o ° o o m > m E a = u > x u c K .`°-
CL
V o
O O Y N d
N O N N N•_ O L C O T 3 0 E O m d d d m m> d m m m W N d O O C m m O d d Y D t m d m
3 0 03sm� m0za 7m mm Urm ° oYwz3m m0 Oz $ v a wU Sam''»m
m m = = m
APPENDIX C
' Wastewater Rate Survey Data - Alphabetical by City
ij
I
u
I
7
L
I
I
J
I
O1GEN11233 \Water Rate StudyW00- 2208.jan.doc
r W W V) V) V!
fA (A
OIM Q M
�', M• V1 �.W
_T
U
T
CD
(4
U
(6
L
_n
Q
(9
T
N
Z
N
N
3
ca
m
Q O'M',Q M'�OIM'.M M Mom Q M Oi- M O Oi0'O m
O -'M,O O C6 4 Q M O>'.,Q'.6 r O- O M M N N!O t r Q (D
fA b3 Hi tA W (A.fA to fA i f9 , tl3fA itA _tA
:V.v'.0 iVlw'I� W ViV V'.V 0 O v V w I�IW
�M OIVjO m ''M'�.MIM M - M 011QQ .- - O.r O ,O O!O CO
.M �N. Q:M. ,(pig 'M N.NN MN M�N M.N.1A'fA•Q;N'N .M �
fA fA fAN3 '.fA :.£9 -tR d�T:fA.M' 69h9 EA'fA HifA f9.d�1K -T di fA EA fA (A �di fH
O m N 0 t� O Q O O Q M M OaO,N.Q O Q.N O M
Q:rn�rno n (pMo
(D Q.(O m m Q'Q 0 N f` M'O: Q'O MIM Q.
i Vi . fR to fA fA FA'. fA. 69 (9 ER � EA E9 (A (A (A fA fA to tR fA fA fA 69 fA
'O
O.O
N:M
r
M O
O
M
O!O
O�
O'OO
Q�
M M
O OO'O
O
M.O
OI
_
N
(x(
OI
�',
»
CD
`•'
'�,�
I
i»in.
I L :
I i
t».tA!�
I
I
e3'
0
is
O I�jQ i(pNiOOIOiQ',
N Q.N;riM (niM O�'O
M NN,��MNIN;NM
fA fA.tA:fA �fA'fA l,(ry'M 69
!Q n M�O616 of '.(O �(O Oiler (n iO N
V' N Q.Lo 6 C N.M O K I N r
fH.(A.M fA to �'�.fA �fA.fA M EA fH M
- - - - -- .- - - -- (p O - -- _. -- - -- - -- - -- - -- - - - - -- - - -- - - -- -
y.0 O n M N O M O Q O (5 O M Q O 00 W Imo. t 0 01 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O'N "O OO) N O 00 O M � I D 0 0 OHO O M O
Q O O M M Q��M MN Q Q ap M M M O ON O'O� O M�CO (p O [p M Of' (D M 0 0 0 M M M
0 N Q Q O M OD M O M [O
m fA EA fA W (A M M ffl fA N N FA fA to FA N M W fA (A (A 69
kA b9 W eA kA fA Ni fA 69 fA (A IA fA fA fA b4
E
0
E
c
0
m
3
m
rn
0 V Co (p (O 00 -_ M r'1 Q r 0
N - N N -- r r r -
R
` - - - M� � � � � � � � � N ft` r N � N ((1 N r .�- � N I� rl N .�- Vl (p (") r I� � �- - - - r N
d
Y
L
O O N N O O O O Q M O M Q O O O O O N O O co Q O O O M O Q O O O O O Q O O O O Q O V M O 0 0
0 0� O 0 � O O_ ( M O O N 0 0 r- ( m 0 0 0 O O� O O N M O O O M O O M M� O O N O N M O M Q O
N (D N t` M M N M M M .- r C6 W O O (o M M M N M O N Q M r M O r co Q N N M m M N M r
4)
E
N
O
N
_
N
CD
oU4.
U
0
'm
L
U
O C
L
0
a U N
N
3
N C C N
f0 L
CI m
O '�
j Ol
3
.�
O O
o
c
N
L
X
O C
O a
E C
L 0
N w
0
O
0
O
C O
y m
0 O
O Q
N
O
Y
N
V
N
C
N
E
Q
C
Q Q
C d N
Q Q Q
(0 Ul N
m m m
N
m
N Ul
m m
m
m m
m
3
m m
3 >. ❑3 (0
m m 0 U
L L L
U 0 U
O
U U U❑
N N N—
O N
W lL
Y>
W W
X
W
f9 N
LL LL
N
LL
LL
N N
(6
N O O O (O O Q O N O7 Q �- o n O O O N O) tD O u'i N N O n (D N N O n of N OJ O lD O M (D O O M N co n 0 (D O
M N M O O Q N Q N m (D Q cD 0 CO r O N M t0 (D Q O) O N
O N (p O O n d0 O Q r O r O N M r (D r 0 n 0 0 0 (D M M n N r n r O) n n r (p r 0) r O7 M fA M (D
b Hi r try r V3 r (p Fry r r y� (y yj r r (/j r r y9 r r r r fA fA fA 69 r r fA (A ffl fA r 69 r to r to r
� fA fA fA fA fA 69 f9 f9 fA fA fA N3 fA V3 fA fA M fA fA (9 fA fA 69 fA fA fA
O
O
O
O
N
d
A
a
L
a+
C
O
W - O b N m O
y M 0
M O O_ Q M (D M (D M m m n 0 0
fR � fA N N � ffi fH fA E9 � to -fA M !H fA � fA N M- V3 � fA (fl to Vi to fA E9 E9 � M M fA fA N3 E9 fA f9 to � 69 � ER b fA � M to kA
A
m
_T
U
T
m
U
f0
L
a
Q
t6
T
N
7
N
N
r.+
3
y
M O'n O O O
O w n M Q W'O O (D O
10 .N �N Q r(p tb:r O O(p
fA fA fA fA M. fA M -.FA 69r f9
� to
rnmrn - rn rn;rn ,� rnrn 'rn ,rn :rn rn'm rn rn•rn rn rn
n
e r r I — .-- — — — — — 'M A
O
O: O O
O
O
— co
- n.0'O
O
it1
N M I O: h W 0 107
' O O
O0
OO
O
O�OO
N
O
O (O N
N'N
rn
Q'WM'N
rQ
N.00
n=
(n.(n
0
n
N W
O
O1¢'1
'Q
U).
.N!N r
riN
r r MMN•W'.
COiN M'W co'n
.� ri0
M.MQ
n'O
r'CO'N
fA .
(fl
Q
M.OiN
r.On
- (D '.Q�n
N
O)
n 6
O'O'(D
f9 ffl �.(A
!V��Vi - M'fA
M fA
fA fA fH E9:Vi
(O
- f9 fA 'Vi.tA fA'.M
'N
(A fA IA
E9 t9 fA
r
fA'kA
fA.�
N
fH
'V�
fA �fA to
fA
/H fH
IA.
'�fA'W
fA
69
IA fA
.69
(H.
tA'EA
M O'n O O O
O w n M Q W'O O (D O
10 .N �N Q r(p tb:r O O(p
fA fA fA fA M. fA M -.FA 69r f9
� to
rnmrn - rn rn;rn ,� rnrn 'rn ,rn :rn rn'm rn rn•rn rn rn
n
e r r I — .-- — — — — — 'M A
O
O: O O
O
O
— O O N
iO
O
it1
N M I O: h W 0 107
' O O
O0
OO
O
O�OO
N
O
O (O N
N'N
rn
Q'WM'N
rQ
Op I(O M (O (OOW
l M
<D
!m,m - m
O
O:Q 0
ifA '.r f9
(D'(O
fA
rn rn.
Q N.M
fA lA fA
- M,O.N
tpr
M'.(D:N N;(D,O
r•(q �.fA.fA�W
Q (D N 6 (O
fA r r!fA
t0 r r W
r 19 :. •(p
4 r
fA .
(fl
'fA
fA
N
(pr
'lA
69
M'.fA:tA b9 'fA
fA fA
f9 ffl �.(A
fA
.
M O'n O O O
O w n M Q W'O O (D O
10 .N �N Q r(p tb:r O O(p
fA fA fA fA M. fA M -.FA 69r f9
� to
rnmrn - rn rn;rn ,� rnrn 'rn ,rn :rn rn'm rn rn•rn rn rn
n
e r r I — .-- — — — — — 'M A
ON O
O!O
010
0
O
O0
OO
,mrn
:rnrn
m
rn
rnrnrnrn
m (D
o
<D
!m,m - m
rn.m.
.rn
rn
rn rn.
u;
M cD
r N
roJ'O
itl
N
(pr
p6
M
Q M M
(D
r.M
(O
M N
M
N
N
r
r
M
O
M
(D
(O
th to
n ; O]
m
m
(D D7�0
O'.O
�
O
(!']
l0
rN
n
r
Q (D •O
n r
0'�(O
�fl
O N
. _
(D,r M�n
_
_
N
_
M
Q
r
Q
N
N
N
_
(O
_
O) n N
�(D
N(D
r
_
N N
r r
N
O
N
O
U
O
Z
M Q
r r
M O'n O O O
O w n M Q W'O O (D O
10 .N �N Q r(p tb:r O O(p
fA fA fA fA M. fA M -.FA 69r f9
� to
rnmrn - rn rn;rn ,� rnrn 'rn ,rn :rn rn'm rn rn•rn rn rn
n
e r r I — .-- — — — — — 'M A
ON O
O!O
010
0
O
O0
OO
mI�'C���N'(D'OO'O'
m (D
o
<D
m
(n
co
o
(n
u;
M cD
r N
roJ'O
itl
N
(pr
p6
M
Q M M
(D
r.M
(O
M N
M
N
N
r
r
M
2
m
m
m
V N
M
N
N.
(A
O
N
O
U
O
Z
0
0
C
C
U
C
O).O
N'U lL:d
O
E
m,C9,J
O•
(6 �O
O
�,
�,.m
U
N
O_'
OI
y
N
U]
C
O !. N N D•
.O
L
C
d
d
N m
T .
Q
C
C C
C
C
C
C.
C
O
3
3 3
3
3
3 0
C
Y
Y j
.U.
C
S x
S S
sm
?
Y
Y
J
J
J
J
J J: J
2,2
2
2
2
2 2
2 ,2
2
2.Z>
ZE
!E
2
2
2
20
z
z
Z
Z
Z Z
Z
Q 0
00
O W O (p O M r 0 0 M _� r O M O M O O - O M N r O r O O r o O
M O O Q N C O O O1 M r (p M N h M ail M (p Q 0 O M OJ N 0 O N LL O Q O O Q N l0 r (p N Q
C M N (D 6 m r M M Q N (p O r r O N N M M m I r Q (p M (O O M M r f�
C M M r (p ( M O Q> O n r (O O N M N r r r M M (p C N O O r M h M
69 fA (A di fA V3 to 69 fA r N £A to to (A fA Vi r kA fA fA r r r r 69 r to to r r r EA 69 f9 69 fA to
� fA (A to fA f9 Vi to 69 fA to b9 (A EA fA to fA fA t9
O
O
O
U
a
m
m
U
co
(4
r
_n
Q
i
(E
(6
T
N
7
N
N
co
3
m
y
m
�i
O
N
1
lJ
N OJ O M O M r 0 0 0 r O M O M O N 0 0 m Q O O O M O O C O O O C O r Q p) �
M
O Q ap O pJ O N O O
fA (A M (A fA fH fA fA (A 69 fA fA (A fry EA tR to to 69 to (A fA (p fA fA fA fA fA ' ffl (A to 69 b9 fA 69 (9 fA fA (fl to fA b9 to fA
O] N O N O N v N Vi M: N O M H O M O I� Q 0 0 0 (p O N O N O O W Q O N O O O Q� t0
(�� � O
MO'O r W n M.O>.N f� c00 O.m o' co W M M CO Q
r fA ffjr tH.tA � r - .N (A r r N.r r N rEH r fA r r to .M rM N r r to � r fA r r to r
fA f9 fA' fA fA' fA f9 tA' V! E9 fA fA fA (A M' (A f9 N3 ' t9 to fA' fA fA fA (A (A (A M M . bh fA fA E9 to ' 69
o o
V V'
O.OIM
U :UJ
,m
(o o (n m - ,U :o
o
M
" -
r r
"LW
m
O �r;O':O
m N'Q'MI(p'o'J
N Q'N
a00'Q:
OJ I��M
O N�OI Olrl(p 4J.M N'�p
O
Q 16' O
.^
Q M
uii(OIn
M
rn.m
fA 1A
69
M't91f9:M
-
- -
(A',EA '.fA'fA:r IN Ib4lr ifA.fA
EPr
m rn
rn
rn rn
f9 '
W '.N U ""
O'. Q'N.O' M:.M:O
V V'
O.OIM
U :UJ
,m
V
N
V V V.
O10'O
M
" -
r r
"LW
m
"
M
m N'Q'MI(p'o'J
aO'00
a00'Q:
(O
Q'.
O
Q 16' O
.^
Q M
uii(OIn
M
rn.m
fA•fA ",fA r,fq (A
N
M't91f9:M
-
- -
m - -
EPr
m rn
rn
rn rn
f9 '
69'E9.fA
'tfl
i r ;
IHl:fA
di
:fA
O OO Q O OO N O (O O O O O!O OW'CO Ni - (O O O O O'O O - i(O -.O NO r Q O 0 X01 010
O'O O O O O C O M:O O'(O O�� O:O'(p.0'N � M Q O M
WOO- try N O QO
n OQ r O
O I� .(p o�0 r O�O'!� -.'n (p'Q O'M Q N O'O Mod C - . (ph N M'�In O N (O o� � Q MN r
O 6 'h v_ O Q M .ry M 0 Ld'N (D'N.M (p :N M q 7 7 Q � ( ( D �p tp 'W M ci,C N Q (O 'W N -- Cr Lr ;'W
N r M r Ld V'N Q r r ry
M
Q. N N �. C Y p( C a N
00°T'0 z EUU'amo mmarnrnrmo�'m'.mm��._ °�mm��cILEvr U)
(0 E E 'O N.L L TD w U m 0 y. W O, > 19 0 O N C C U'M J ! 2 '.a1 3 3. T. 0. 0 E O m� O U C y in E O
>i >` m N U O O O O O O 7 N N W L L L Q O. N ._ N L > i N
_ «
oa(L �ma' Of mOf �ctcl ( n(n'(n'(n(nw(5U)(n(n(nin(ncn''n nl�r'� > > >��������� ��
__-
OM
_ —__..
r'Q I� Q
M'O
Q
M
_.._ _ -----
- N_1�
r "r _
M c0
_
(p (p'Q f�
_
n M
(O
<V _.�.
rn m .rn rn
rn rn
- rn � rn rn
rn�rn.rn
M '
MM
rn m - rn.rn
M
rn.m
M M M M
rn - - -
- - —
-
- -
m - -
- - - -
m rn
rn
rn rn
Q
-
o
Q O
O M
M O
O M tp O O
O M O
O O O
O
O OO Q O OO N O (O O O O O!O OW'CO Ni - (O O O O O'O O - i(O -.O NO r Q O 0 X01 010
O'O O O O O C O M:O O'(O O�� O:O'(p.0'N � M Q O M
WOO- try N O QO
n OQ r O
O I� .(p o�0 r O�O'!� -.'n (p'Q O'M Q N O'O Mod C - . (ph N M'�In O N (O o� � Q MN r
O 6 'h v_ O Q M .ry M 0 Ld'N (D'N.M (p :N M q 7 7 Q � ( ( D �p tp 'W M ci,C N Q (O 'W N -- Cr Lr ;'W
N r M r Ld V'N Q r r ry
M
Q. N N �. C Y p( C a N
00°T'0 z EUU'amo mmarnrnrmo�'m'.mm��._ °�mm��cILEvr U)
(0 E E 'O N.L L TD w U m 0 y. W O, > 19 0 O N C C U'M J ! 2 '.a1 3 3. T. 0. 0 E O m� O U C y in E O
>i >` m N U O O O O O O 7 N N W L L L Q O. N ._ N L > i N
_ «
oa(L �ma' Of mOf �ctcl ( n(n'(n'(n(nw(5U)(n(n(nin(ncn''n nl�r'� > > >��������� ��
I
� -O Q
Q O
O M
M O
O M tp O O
O M O
O O O
O
Q. N N �. C Y p( C a N
00°T'0 z EUU'amo mmarnrnrmo�'m'.mm��._ °�mm��cILEvr U)
(0 E E 'O N.L L TD w U m 0 y. W O, > 19 0 O N C C U'M J ! 2 '.a1 3 3. T. 0. 0 E O m� O U C y in E O
>i >` m N U O O O O O O 7 N N W L L L Q O. N ._ N L > i N
_ «
oa(L �ma' Of mOf �ctcl ( n(n'(n'(n(nw(5U)(n(n(nin(ncn''n nl�r'� > > >��������� ��
APPENDIX D
' Wastewater Rate Survey Data - By Population
I
I
u
I
I
I
I
'�
' O:NGEN%12331Water Rate Study%400.2208.jan.doc
C
O
7
a
0
IL
T
Co
L
N
(6
0
T
N
7
U)
N
M
v
N
m
(0
3
a�
N
O
O
O
N
O
C
O
2
O
Q
O
O
O
M
O
O
r
O
r
O
W
N
1�
O
O
O
O
M
tO
V
N
LO
I�
0
0
t`
O
O
O
O
V
LO
N
V
LO
m
M
LO
O
N
m
(D
W
O
O
N
r
m
M
r
m
to
(
0
O
r
69
r
to
r
m
r
r
M
m
r
O
N
m
I
r
Ln
m
W
O
LO
N
O
V
r
O
m
r
69
N
6
fo
r
W
fA
r
to
r
(p
N
r
vi
69
M
fA
69
r
r
Vi
tp
r
(o
r
r
69
.-
W
r
to
r
V>
69
fA
69
fo
69
FA
FA
69
69
69
V)
69
69
to
O
O
O
M
O
O
r
O
f�
O
O
m
(�
O
O
O
O
M
LO
m
N
LO
r
O
O
r
O
O
O
O
r
tO
N
V
LO
O
O
m
m
O
LO
M
LO
r
0
m
M
m
0
0
0
N
M
M
Ln
N
N
V
In
LO
r
O
O
M
O
N
V
r
LO
LO
LO
N
m
M
m
V
N
(D
V
m
m
m
fD
LO
N
O
O
M
M
O
0
(D
M
N
m
N
V
V
O
r
t\
Vi
r
N
N
6
r
69
N
N
r
LO
M
N
O
r
N
69
69
fo
fA
69
(f)
to
V3
to
fA
fA
fo
FA
to
l0
69
69
to
to
M
69
69
V3
to
69
fA
tH
FA
69
fo
69
fA
0
0
0
lf')
O
O
r
O
r
O
M
m
I�
O
O
O
LO
M
LO
m
N
LO
O
tO
LO
N
O
O
LO
O
M
LO
N
m
0
O
O
m�
O
LO
m
LO
r
O
V
m
r
0
0
Cl
M
M
r
0
m
O
O
m
O
N
V
Mrl-
m
LO
V
m
m
LO
V
N
m
m
m
m
I-
m
LO
O
r
m
M
m
.--
O
V
LO
N
r
.--
(D
M
N
V
I-
M
V
Vt
fA
N
69
_V
to
fA
r
M
r
M
EA
N
Vl
r
V
N
N
69
N
r
69
N
fA
fA
to
6Y
64
(fl
fo
fA
fA
fA
fA
fA
FA
(fl
FA
Vl
to
69
M
fA
fA
fo
69
to
fo
ffl
O
O
O
(l-
M
0
0
0
r
O
O
O�
O
O
O
O
M
V
m
"
LO
O
M
LO
M
O
O
O
O
O
LO
M
I�
N
0
0
m
r
M
0
0
LO
r
O
r
0
(D
O
O
O
LO
M
m
O
N
M
0
m
n
m
O
O
M
N
N
V
m
r
N
tD
(D
m
N
m
m
m
m
V
m
0
0
m
m
m
O
N
CO
O
m
M
m
V
M
V
r
V
LO
M
r
O
N
N
N
I-
r
fo
CO
(p
to
r
to
brJ
r
to
r
r
V1
to
r
fo
W
6
69
W
t6
r
M
W
r
(0
69
fA
69
to
fA
to
fA
to
69
w
to
to
w
to
fo
to
fo
to
m
r
co
N
r
r
V
N
M
(D
m
V
(D
V
t`
LO
(D
U�
V
M
m(
N
rn
rn
rn
m
m
rn
m
rn
rn
rn
m
rn
rn
rn
rn
rn
rn
rn
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
M
M
rn
rn
M
rn
N
LO
O
O
O
O
O
r
m
O
O
M
O
O
r
O
0
0
V
0
0
0
LO
O
O
r
0
0
0
V
0
tO
(O
O
N
(O
LO
r
M
O
O
O
r
O
O
N
m
O
m
r
M
M
M
M
V
tO
LO
LO
m
n
r
r
m
m
m
m
MOO=
_
_
N
N
N
N
N
N
L
u
(9
a
(U
a)
Y
Y
-
`
J
lO
m
'O
N
N
L
O
d
0
0
v
m&
O
m
o
J
U
`�
`m
>
(D
a
=
a'
a�
ti
n
o
a
°
3
rU
Z
c
_
c
0
L
V
C
N
m
m
C
U
U
N
rn
N
co
co
(U
N
C
g
N
_
�'
p
.N
X
m
W
Q
Z
2
2
2
H�
U
U
2
m
m
W
Y
2
_
(!'
U
J
J
m
W
Q
(n
M
M
(D
D)
K
N
co
1O
N
W
N
O
tD
O
O
w
m = m m m m = m = m = = m = m
A O N Qi0 m Of m mr Yl O d O n O O N N nA Q'Q (O N O N C]O O 10 OO�O � -0'm O OO m O m mr - Of O'm mn O'.O O N A.O f0:� 0147
m m n m•O d m d Om N O PN m m N O 47 m Q d m T N O c'7•m O O N m.0 N d.N � O m O.m O P m m m OO N m N.O Om P O Om In �m
m A O�m mm M � N O7 M'O O. m� O1 Q o'1'.N m'm O O) r M m.m M O O rr7 m m'm O d N N.m •- 'N A� p7.� N.P dN N, rm O'A
w � �'w w � "w w -w w.� � w � N w w� w'wlw w N w w� � ww � �w� �' w. w�� w ww.� Imo•.
w w w w w ww w.wi ww.ww w w w w w. w ww w- w w'.w 'w 'w w w'w' wi w
n o N d o m m w o r7n rP o. n'o o' m r'od dP cO - o - N',o o'o m�mbb a'lo d'o 0 o'a7 bm'
m m r Q O m m N O m N O d N m m m d u'7 m �Q Q �- - m O7�m O m N'N'O w N'm m0 IA O Om'm r O w O n P'm O m m 0 O'n 70'07
wWN N w N w w W N w , w WW wMW N w gwWNWWWNWWw. w W W N w . w WW N w N w , W ww W w.w�Ww
n Q n m O N Q 0�0 n m t•l d 0 n 0 m O A N.P d d N n 0 Q N O M Om m O N N O N
w w w w wwwww w w w w w w w w w� w w w w w www ww w w w w w wwww w w www w w w w in w
r m N m 0 �'7 O N m n N P O O n 0 N O c7 N O P O O O O m m O m O 0 0 0 0 0 w O N O 0 0 m 0 t7 O7 O CJ M O w m O m 0 0 0 0 0 r
m 47 N �7 O m O c'] A m O7 m m m m m m O M m L Q O m t7 m N N O N m m N r m O N m m w 0 0 Q m M Q O N c7 O d m m t7 O O O O m Q
w w w w w w w w w w w w in w w w w w w in
nmrn nn drN rn r rr nnv7mQm�mAmA�nQmmrmmmn mm� ra+ m mmmmo7r mrrAPrnm
ma7m mmo+m m mrnm m m mrnm a7rnm msa7 m mrnmm� rnmm mo7rnmmo7mm m m m m m mm ma7rn a7 rnm
m N O1 N N •= m n N N Ip I� O) N n i C'1 m �' m Q7 Q al N N n N
N N N N N N N N N N N N ('f [7 (7 t'1 C1 (+] (7 t+I ty t7 M M (h Ih M r•'I M M c7 Q P Q P Q d V] m m O m L� m m m m m n A m m m m m O) Q) OI O
^
N y
`M Y 0 LL
d W O a0 y ) _ @ t @ O T _ N N LL C W H D x O y Y w C N @
= L E Q O p m J O@ L L y a lL '@ O IL L E pO
< O@ 01 N; O_ @ E N N JI m C O 2 O U L Y C O. O N a O C` Y O. 6 U LL O N LL UI N U O@ L O U m . J O W V OI = LL > Y a N@ C (J O
ry >@ O@ N U1 '> >>�. C L C O >i C N U U@ T C u C O y d; J Y N N >i @? Y@ N N W L O C@ t0 0 C 0 a_ O O A W 7.01
LL> U O> Q. (n J J m Q Z E O @ N 0 'U N@ 3 U @ @ @> N @ L N O 6 41 L @ ..• O
Z( in a0co00m,U�m`mz >00 wz3:05 QU z2 22 :2 ¢v»Lm
(V it .O W NiN O c oo V - W W M O �O'O W O W W
O) W M M MGM o 0 o Prn � M rn o 0 0 BMW W.-•rn o (n W a r u,
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . ... . . . .
w w w w w. w:w tl9 'ww w.w w w w
C
O
7
a
O
a
T
m
c0
M
0
a
W
7
O7
c0
N
f0
3
W
m
J
d
3
W
N
__ N aJ M O O
- m`r W W W. of — o�M _o - __
N N N N N M N N P N N N
w -w'Iw w ww w w w w ww w.w w
117 m�! r O h.n
ww w w w� w w Nw w
i
ri r o
10 O P (
'N O W rlO
w w w wiw
N W O W
W W V)
w
L-1
N.OI 0 O'Oir.Wl.-
.O (O.OIP O'P'M;W I�
��w wlww ww,ww
I
r
(c
h
W
i
j
_- - O I O �_ N - -.- - - - - -_ - - O.W W�(O N (O.W O O N�WiM M
O N
O1 N w w 't N � 9 0 0 0 O � w �.a � M ( NiO W P OIOf O r h
O O) O W W
W � W W O O �O W W P N r 0 0 (O V1 N ' CO W (O N r N i (O P
�I
M'W O M M — M � M. N W'W N (O co P WIM'M '.P r MAP P.N'.O (O rIOI' Nip'. O) WIM WIOI� Wi(O M
w w w w w w- w- w w w w w w w- w w.w w w w'w w.69 w wlw w wl l w p
O O O -O O O O O �n O W O O O M O O W O O H O (O (V O N O O I - 6 - 0 - ) i0 O l O M r r
m O M W
w o w w w w w w w ww w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w 0 0) 0 0)
w w w w w w w w w w w w w 1n w o w
w
@
O P
Q1 Ql m - m - - - T m m - - - m m m m m - O - - T - m - - - - -
7 .- - � O � 7 7
�- . N G! AC�iT� b N w b
0
O
GI
N
A
O
L
O O O M (O O O O O O O O N O O O O N O O O O W O GJ O O O P O O O O O O W O O N O O O O O
O N O) N
O
@ N
Z
N N co t'I M P W O O Ld (N W r r n W W O O - M i0 W r W co O N W W M P W r 0 W O O O W W
N
�
r � � •' � - � � � � � �-- '- � � � �
UJ
�
C
O
v LL ca N
N W a C
�
d 0 C LL L
Q
m
N
L
O
@ N
A
C
O J
W W O
O
v LL ca N
N W a C
y C U
d 0 C LL L
O
O
O-
O
O L L .S S .S Y O
O) @« m fn O 2 m
O1. 6
> T >` Ol (C W
W 1 'p o �O '� T 7
@ 7
O O
a
w
E m a n E m
.S
> 3 a w E o - 'm m
o d o °' =° c r
a W � a (° c` o E 5
c d
o °-
W
O@
O @@ O W O L
'L] 3 3
O@@ W 3 L >
O a p@ U_
O d. @ N C O >`
C
N LQ O
¢
W W
LL z 2 2= LL z� co U V]
@- C > � j W W >
V] (n Z 2 LL' U
_>
C m 2
�; J O
2 2
O
Q Q> Z Z>
V) LL U LL'
Q V) W C] m LL 0
V)
N A
m